[BidClub_]
The a16z Show · · 45 分钟

为什么一位互联网先驱认为最初的模式已经失灵

Joel de la GarzaBarrett Lyon

AI与软件技术政策
YouTube ↗
TL;DR
  • Barrett Lyon 认为,随着通信围绕企业服务器集中、政策逐步迁移到网络层,互联网最初的开放模式已经失灵。 Carrier-grade NAT 削弱了点对点应用,而身份和年龄控制错误地把“一个 IP 地址”当成“驾照”。他针对 WhatsApp、Signal、iMessage、Telegram 和 VPN 的核心问题看似简单:“那是谁的服务器?”

  • Docs.net 是 Lyon 试图通过可编程的并行网络,恢复直接、私密通信的尝试。 其内部生态包含196个互联网上不存在的域名、API驱动的资源配置、mesh 和公网地址,以及点对点通话、视频、聊天和文件传输。Lyon 称,手机可以直接互传文件;系统还可以在私有网络内以低延迟在不同分支之间传输20GB文件,并提供“最多3至4层加密”。

  • 真正值得投资者区分的,是基础设施归谁所有,因为隐私承诺的可信度只能取决于其底层硬件和合作方。 Lyon 调查 VPN 服务商后的结论非常绝对:“如果设备不是自己的,就无法制定政策。”因此,Docs.net 掌控“从软件到布线”的全栈;Lyon 描述了美国和欧洲分开的运营体系,其中一家瑞士公司负责欧洲业务。公司还将所有权和治理结构公开化。

  • AI 让一家约12人的公司在6个月内、无需网络管理员或系统管理员,便在全球建成26个站点。 Agent 在公司自有硬件上负责网络运维,联系人和推理结果均在内部处理。其安全逻辑既是技术问题,也是组织问题:能够接触网络的员工越少,内部威胁面就越小。

  • Lyon 认为,无处不在的遥测数据与可规模化的“投币即用型智能系统”结合,才是AI转型中真正危险的部分。 单个追踪事件看似无害,但汇总后的数据可以暴露收入、日常作息、购买行为、生育、离婚及其他人生变化——有时甚至“早于你的配偶知道”。一旦数百万个智能单元都能查询这套数据,监控和定向说服的成本就会大幅下降。

  • 本期反常识的基础设施判断是:应捍卫数据中心,同时攻击围绕数据中心搭建的追踪系统。 Lyon 和 Joel de la Garza 反驳数据中心持续“喝水”的说法,解释称,封闭系统只有在设备故障或水分蒸发时才需要补水。他们认为,这些设施能创造技术岗位,也会改善周边基础设施。两人的更尖锐结论是:“人们真正应该针对的,不是数据中心,而是追踪系统。”

  • Lyon 最新的项目延续了他的职业轨迹:把亲身遭遇的互联网故障转化为共享基础设施。 一次高中时期的 DDoS 问题催生了 Prolexic;DefenseNet 后来成为 F5 Silverline;BitGravity 解决了视频分发中的浪费;而一场$50的赌局最终产出了 Opte 互联网地图,其中两件作品进入 MoMA 永久馆藏。这条反复出现的路径,是把亲身遭遇的故障转化为共享基础设施。

摘要 · 为研究而整理的核心内容

1. 一次发动机故障,让抽象风险变得残酷具体

  • De la Garza 先讲了 Lyon 这段特殊通勤经历的由来:当湾区驾车时间从15分钟拉长到接近45分钟,Lyon 开始在工作地和 Tahoe 附近的家人之间往返飞行。在一次从 San Carlos 起飞后遭遇发动机故障之前,他已经驾驶 Sirus 飞机累计约1,300小时;这次故障迫使他决定在哪里坠落,避免伤及他人。

  • Lyon 曾考虑打开飞机的弹道降落伞——事故报告显示,一些飞行员因拒绝使用降落伞而死亡——但他发现滑翔距离内有一座大型前军事机场,最终在那里降落。直到一名消防员握住他的手,“一阵突如其来的恐惧”才袭来;在那之前,这只是一个需要按程序处理的问题。

  • 这次故障并非一个单一、清晰的事件。Lyon 称,进气控制部件发生断裂,金属进入歧管,似乎影响了3号和6号汽缸;新安装的电子点火系统失效,备用磁电机也在更高转速下停止工作。他最终卖掉了飞机,并得出结论:今后的飞机应该拥有“更少的活动部件”。De la Garza 还建议配备备用飞行员和备用系统,Lyon 对此表示认同。

2. 网络的政策层正在被要求承担错误的职能

  • Docs.net 让 Lyon 重新连接到自己少年时代的黑客身份和第一桩生意:在云服务出现之前,他曾以每月$5的价格向最多1,000名用户出售 shell 账号;公司关闭后,他仍保留了那个域名。新项目延续了他对协议的迷恋,但所针对的却是一个在他看来已经停滞的互联网:“没什么新的东西,一切都建立在已有之上。”

  • 他的技术批评指向 carrier-grade NAT:它“正在摧毁应用执行酷炫功能的能力”,因为它阻断了直接连接。如今,强大的边缘 Wi-Fi、mesh 协议和点对点网络已经具备实用条件,Lyon 希望找回早期互联网作为不受限制的“充满巨大创意的市场”的承诺。

  • Lyon 的政策反对同样是架构层面的。他认为,政策运动越来越要求网络执行年龄、身份和内容限制,尽管“网络并不承担身份验证功能”,而且“IP 地址不是驾照”。如果必须限制访问,决策就应该放在其他层,而不是不加区分地嵌入连接本身。

  • 错误分类会让这些控制更加危险:本地信息服务商可能误判用户所在地,从而适用错误司法辖区的政策;自动过滤器也可能把合法服务标记为成人内容。De la Garza 举了一个以合作为导向的聊天机器人业务的例子:一半分类器把它判定为成人内容。问题不只是使用不便,而是脆弱的标签如何演变成网络层面的排除机制。

3. Docs.net 用私有端到端交换取代经服务器中转的消息传递

  • Lyon 将传统 VPN 描述为连接到租用出口服务器的加密通道:它有助于把身份与 IP 地址分离,但本质上只是权宜之计。Docs.net 则提供一个可以通过 API 调整的网络,允许在包含196个互联网上不存在的域名的内部生态中,在几毫秒内创建域名、公网或 mesh 地址以及各种策略。

  • 创建账户需要解一道简单的谜题,用户由此获得一个 token。用户可以更换 token,也可以删除账户后重新创建。邀请朋友时,系统会在后台交换证书并建立信任,不会把密码学工具直接摆到用户面前——设计上的经验是:“如果你告诉人们这是 PKI,它就无法正常工作。”Lyon 戏称这一结果为“Private Key Infrastructure”(私钥基础设施),因为公钥层被隐藏在普通聊天界面之后。

  • Lyon 对 WhatsApp、Signal、iMessage 和 Telegram 的批评是:这些服务看起来像是在把数据发送给另一个人,实际却是先上传到服务器,再由对方取回。因此,“那是谁的服务器?”才是关键问题。在 Docs.net 上,手机通过 mesh 通信,同时自身也充当服务器:“完全不需要中间人或服务器。”

  • 他说,这套架构支持直接通话、视频、聊天和文件传输,不会暴露电话号码、电子邮箱或姓名。系统可以在私有网络内以低延迟在不同分支之间传输最大20GB的文件,最多提供3至4层加密。不过,隐私并不意味着不受法律约束:Lyon 明确表示,网络仍必须“尽可能”遵守适用法律。

4. 只有运营方拥有全栈,隐私承诺才真正可信

  • De la Garza 对信任的质疑,比泛泛偏好加密更尖锐:一家声称保护隐私的公司,如果不披露谁拥有它、为何存在、有哪些参与者,依然无法令人信服。本期的警示案例是一项由 FBI 创建、专门出售给有组织犯罪团伙的安全通信服务;独家销售和安全品牌都没有揭示真正的运营方。

  • 免费 VPN 面临同样悬而未决的委托—代理问题。Lyon 说:“如果你不付钱,你就是产品。”但即便是收费服务商的“无日志”政策,也留下了诸多问题:服务器是自有还是租赁的,出租方是谁,机柜之外发生什么,服务商是否真的能执行它宣称的规则?

  • Lyon 最终得出的结论是:“如果设备不是自己的,就无法制定政策。”因此,Docs.net 控制着软件、设备、布线、路由,以及运行在自有硬件上的 AI 组件。Lyon 还介绍了区域拆分:美国业务在美国法律框架下运营,欧洲业务则由一家瑞士公司负责。团队强调透明的所有权和治理结构,而不是要求用户相信一个无名的隐私标签。

5. AI 压缩运营成本,遥测数据则放大威胁

  • Docs.net 依靠一支约12人的团队,在大约6个月内利用冗余路由在全球建成26个站点。Lyon 称,公司既没有网络管理员,也没有系统管理员:“一切都由 AI 处理。”这些 Agent 在 Docs.net 硬件上的安全环境内运行,使联系人、推理结果及其他运营数据不会流向大型外部 AI 服务商。

  • De la Garza 表示,最严重的网络攻击都与内部威胁有关,Lyon 对此表示认同。小团队意味着能够接触网络的人更少;实体设备受到监控,摄像头公司的 Agent 会针对移动或可疑活动发出警报。团队甚至考虑过《碟中谍》式的激光系统,但数据中心的灯无法关闭,因此无法让激光束显现出来。

  • 更大的危险来自 AI 与广告遥测数据的结合。Lyon 认为,广告商可能已经“远远领先于情报机构”:遍布应用和网站的追踪器可以汇总咖啡习惯、起床时间、收入、购物模式和重大人生事件。问题不在于是否有人关心某一次 Target 内裤购买,而在于这份组合记录能够重建一个人的人生。

  • 可规模化的“投币即用型智能系统”改变了利用这份记录的经济学。数百万个此类单元可以与海量遥测数据配套部署,而智能能力让有效定向成为可能。Lyon 的处方是,在应用层和网络层拆除追踪机制,恢复一个人们可以连接和建设、无需持续受到广告商或政府观察的互联网。

6. 数据中心反弹针对的是社会仍然需要的基础设施

  • Lyon 和 De la Garza 认为,围绕数据中心的大量评论要么缺乏技术常识,要么受到了操纵。他们反驳设施持续“喝水”的描述:Lyon 称,只有设备出现故障或发生蒸发时才需要补水;De la Garza 则描述了一个封闭系统——如果冷水机故障、需要排空系统,就必须重新注水。

  • 他们对数据中心的经济判断同样直接。大型设施能带来高薪技术岗位并吸引高科技人才;De la Garza 认为,周边基础设施和网络连接也会随之改善。尽管公众争议不断,Lyon 称自己走访20多个站点时并没有看到成群的抗议者,有时现场只有“田里的一只兔子”。

  • 两人怀疑,当反数据中心叙事在多个平台上系统性出现时,公众舆论可能正被操纵,以服务商业利益,但他们没有指出具体责任方。他们给出的结论更狭窄,也更绝对:在这一技术转折点削弱数据中心基础设施是“错误的决定”;而消除广告追踪,则会让生活轻松得多。

7. Lyon 一再把个人遭遇的失败转化为共享基础设施

  • Lyon 追溯称,Prolexic 源于朋友们对他高中服务器发起的攻击。他将应对经验整理成一次 SANS 演讲,随后开始有人联系他;问题又从圣诞销售期间对两家手表公司的攻击,升级到 Super Bowl 前让博彩网站瘫痪。由于很少有公司负担得起必要设备,Prolexic 将其作为租赁服务提供,成为最早的云服务之一。这项业务后来以 Akamai Prolexic 的形式延续下来。

  • DefenseNet 后来成为 F5 Silverline,BitGravity 则把同样的系统思维应用于视频分发。Lyon 回忆称,当观众跳转到视频中段时,渐进式下载会浪费昂贵的带宽;因此,公司围绕大文件、大对象和视频专用分发搭建了技术体系。

  • Opte 项目始于午餐时的一场$50赌局:Lyon 能否把内部网络地图工具改造成覆盖整个互联网的工具。一次自行车事故让他无法行走,也给了他编程的时间;最终产出的项目及其地图和动画在各地博物馆巡展,其中两件作品进入 MoMA 永久馆藏。第二天早上,他的反应不是胜利感,而是冒名顶替综合征:“我还会有一天觉得自己是艺术家吗?”

  • Lyon 还提到一本书,他认为书中写到了 Prolexic 的起步以及追踪俄罗斯网络犯罪分子的经历,只是这些事件在当时看起来都很普通。这种执着与不确定感,构成了本期节目的收束。无论是绘制互联网地图、搭建 Burning Man 项目,还是重构私有网络,Lyon 始终相信,热情会创造一种别人能够感受到的“气场”。他坚持认为,Docs.net “才刚刚开始”。

完整逐字稿
Barrett Lyon

We are currently standing at a truly critical turning point. Large-scale, literally coin-operated intelligent systems are being born. The Internet is quite stagnant in terms of protocol design. There isn’t much new, and everything is built on top of what already exists. I’m trying to change that very situation.

Joel de la Garza

As you mentioned, you’ve established a temporary method that allows people to connect and converse without leaving a record.

Barrett Lyon

The real problem lies in apps like WhatsApp, Signal, iMessage, and Telegram. These apps pretend to be sending a message to someone, but in reality, they’re sending it to a server. Whose server is that? That’s the point.

Joel de la Garza

It’s regrettable that, at this critical turning point for the future of our country and technology, conversations are taking place that appear to be manipulated for some purpose.

Barrett Lyon

It really feels like it’s been manipulated. In my opinion, for future technology, we need to build this kind of infrastructure right now.

Joel de la Garza

1. Barrett's engine failure over Oakland

If we’re messing things up, today we have Barrett Lyon, perhaps one of the most interesting figures in the technology industry.

Barrett Lyon

I have so many stories to share.

Joel de la Garza

Every time we meet, I’m always amazed, because the new stories you tell make everything I’ve done so far look insignificant. The most interesting story I heard recently was one I had never heard before, and I think it was probably when we invested in your previous company.

Since you’re a pilot and have a pilot’s license, you said you decided to optimize your life through flying, right? I heard that you had an unpleasant experience on your way back after the meeting with us.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. One day, I was driving to work in the San Francisco Bay Area, and I realized that a trip that used to take 15 minutes was now taking almost 45 minutes. My family lives in the Tahoe area, so I thought, “I could get there in about the same amount of time by plane. I can just commute that way.”

That was before working from home became official because of COVID-19. I had to go in person to get a physical examination.

Joel de la Garza

So you started flying, and you flew every day?

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that’s right. I had flown about 1,300 hours on a Sirus aircraft. One day, after finishing a meeting, I boarded the plane and took off from San Carlos.

The engine started having problems around Auckland Airport. I thought water might have gotten into the fuel, so I climbed, and it seemed fine after passing the Bravo level. But at that very moment, the engine stopped completely.

Joel de la Garza

What were you thinking at that moment?

Barrett Lyon

I texted my friends, “Guys, it’s Bisang. I love you.” I wasn’t sure what to do. I thought, “Just declare a state of emergency and think, ‘Okay, where should I crash so it doesn’t harm people?’”

I tried to think through my options. I found a field, but it turned out I was at a fairly high altitude, and there was a huge airport right next to it.

Joel de la Garza

Was it Oakland?

Barrett Lyon

No, it wasn’t Oakland. It was Buchanan Field. I can’t quite remember the name of the city. It was a huge old military airport—Alameda? No, it was a different place, the airport on the other side of the mountain range.

I think it was Buchanan Field, but anyway, I landed there. Before that, I went toward the field and asked myself, “Okay, I have a parachute. Should I deploy the ballistic parachute?”

From the crash reports I’ve read, the reason pilots die is that they don’t use their parachutes. The airport was right over there, but I was still in flight.

The real irony of that airplane is that, despite being technically the safest airplane in history, it’s involved in the most crashes because people don’t use the safety devices.

Joel de la Garza

Right.

Barrett Lyon

Of course, the safety device works, but it can also damage the airplane. A rocket is launched from the tail section, tearing off parts of the airplane and completely destroying it, so there’s no guarantee that you can land safely. The seat has a shock absorber, so it absorbs some of the impact when it hits the ground.

Joel de la Garza

How quickly does all of this happen? How many minutes would it be? Or might it be shorter than that?

Barrett Lyon

It might be shorter than that. Anyway, I made a landing call, landed, and drove straight into the temporary parking lot.

I was a bit flustered and bewildered when I got off the plane. You know those big fire trucks? There was a really big one. It looked like it had been made by a child, but it was enormous.

The firefighter got out of the truck and grabbed my hand. At that moment, a sudden wave of fear washed over me. I realized that this person was the one who was going to put out the fire. It was dizzying. Then I thought, “What do I do now? I have to get home somehow.”

I didn’t want to rent a car or drive home myself. With that thought in mind, I decided there was no need to worry anymore. The danger was too great.

I kept that plane for a while and eventually took it to Las Vegas to sell it.

Joel de la Garza

Did you figure out what the problem was or what had caused it?

Barrett Lyon

Yes. Three really strange things happened at the same time. One was an air-intake control valve—a kind of lever—where a piece of metal broke off and got sucked into the air-intake manifold. It went down to the oil pan, and I think it got stuck in cylinders 3 and 6.

That caused an electrical problem related to the spark, and that spark was controlled by the newly installed electronic fuel injector (electronic ignition system). It stopped working. The ignition failed halfway, and at the same time, the backup magneto on the opposite side also stopped working.

Joel de la Garza

I see.

Barrett Lyon

It was like a series of strange breakdowns occurred. The strange thing is that the magneto worked very slightly on the ground. The engine would start, but as the RPM went up, it would just shut off.

Anyway, that was the reason. It took some time to figure out the cause. It was quite an interesting experience on the way home.

Joel de la Garza

That could happen. Now you know why the Pope kisses the ground when he gets off the plane, right?

Barrett Lyon

Yes. If I were to have another airplane in my life, I would choose one with fewer moving parts.

Joel de la Garza

It would be better to have reserve pilots and reserve systems, though.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, and the more you fly, the higher the risk becomes.

Joel de la Garza

I think that incident triggered various things. We gathered today to talk about your new business. It seems like a very unusual thing for you—something more deeply related to your life and more important.

So, shall we talk a little about Docs.net? Could you explain why you decided to create Docs.net? First, could you tell me what Docs.net is and what motivated you? I’d also appreciate it if you could share your thoughts on why it’s important and why you created it now.

2. What Doxxnet actually is

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that’s good. First, let me explain the name. When I was young, my hacker nickname was Docs. I started a business called Docs.net with a friend when I was in high school, before cloud services came out.

It was a business that rented servers and provided user accounts for a fee. I made a pretty good profit during my high school years.

Joel de la Garza

Were these shell accounts?

Barrett Lyon

Yes, they were shell accounts. I sold shell accounts for $5 a month, and there were as many as 1,000 users. The service offered various features, and people liked it, so a small community formed for a while.

However, after graduating from high school and closing my business, I started working. I left the domain as it was.

I’m also very interested in protocol design, and I find it intriguing that the Internet is somewhat stagnant in terms of protocol design. There isn’t much new, and everything is built on top of what already exists.

As I watched censorship intensify, people’s privacy being violated, and various other things happening, the emergence of VPNs made it really interesting to try creating a kind of alternative network.

A VPN is a network designed from the ground up to protect people from advertisers, trackers, malware, and foreign forces attempting to detect user activity.

The original promise of the Internet was that it was a marketplace of tremendous ideas—a market without restrictions and without censorship. It seems that many of the early founders of the Internet were extreme advocates of freedom of expression.

Joel de la Garza

That was for a very specific user base, but as you mentioned, the situation has changed dramatically over the past few years, hasn’t it?

Barrett Lyon

Yes, and now it has fallen into the hands of several companies. China is a good example, with companies like China Netcom and China Telecom.

Joel de la Garza

Where is China Netcom?

Barrett Lyon

Anyway, they’re using that network to manipulate the entire population and force a different decision-making process upon people.

The Internet was originally designed with a more open concept, so reviving that openness is one of the things I wanted to do. Think about the pre-Internet era—that is, a very old wireless network like ALOHAnet. It was wireless communication using packet modems and similar technology.

Now that we can use really powerful Wi-Fi at the edge, there’s a tremendous opportunity to create better mesh protocols and peer-to-peer networks.

One of the biggest problems with the entire Internet is carrier-grade NAT. NAT is destroying the ability of applications to perform cool functions. I’m trying to solve this very problem.

Joel de la Garza

All right.

3. When censorship comes home to the US

Barrett Lyon

Another interesting point is that we always talk about foreign governments restricting Internet access. They mainly mention China and Russia. However, recently I went somewhere where a customer-identity-verification system was being implemented, and access to certain websites was being blocked.

Joel de la Garza

If it is a website they define as inappropriate, it could be anything. It could be a health-related website or any other website. So we are witnessing censorship becoming increasingly severe even within the United States.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, it is slowly spreading in the United States as well, but it is proceeding in a somewhat strange way. There are many cases where people ask the network to resolve identity-verification issues. But the network does not perform identity-verification functions, does it?

The network is not holding a hammer and driving nails. An IP address is not a driver’s license. It does not make sense to restrict network usage based on things like age. That is a problem that needs to be approached from a different layer.

If you want to restrict usage for a specific reason, you need to do it in a very different way rather than leaving it to the network. Such movements have started to appear in the United States as well and are already emerging in other countries.

In addition to age restrictions, there was an incident not long ago in which Google, Cisco, and Umbrella filed lawsuits against French telecommunications companies. Even though they are not based in France, a regulation was introduced there to block more than 100 piracy sites. Then they said, “No, we are going to launch a scorched-earth operation. We are going to blockade all of France.”

If you do that, the repercussions will inevitably be greater. If a local information provider mistakenly identifies a user’s location, that user will also be subject to the same policy. It is really terrible. Those kinds of classification problems are always the worst.

Joel de la Garza

For example, we were reviewing an investment opportunity in a company that builds chatbots focused on partnerships or collaborations, but half of the classification engines classified the site as adult content. This is a legitimate online dating and marriage site. It is not as though they are doing anything illegal.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, we also had a bit of trouble because of Dox. I think it is because the word “Dox” has two x’s in it.

Joel de la Garza

Ah, so you are heading that way now.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. However, in the end, it worked to our advantage. Claude recognized us, so after we completed the proper registration process and applied, everything became available. It was really good.

Joel de la Garza

4. Why VPNs don't cut it

I think that as this information totalitarianism gradually spreads, various products that we are all familiar with have come into existence. VPNs are probably the most common example. So I think it would be good to hear in more detail why existing tools are insufficient, why Dox was created, and how it differs from existing tools. It would be good to share our thoughts on that process in more depth.

Barrett Lyon

It seems like VPNs mostly just serve as connection and exit points. They rent a server from a landlord, install software on it, and access the internet through an encrypted connection. Then all requests and operations on the internet are carried out through that server.

This is intended to resolve the issue of using IP addresses as identities, as we discussed earlier. You could say it is a kind of workaround. People also think that this method is more helpful for security. Of course, you could argue against it, but it is actually a very basic principle.

Such a network can be adjusted in real time. By applying APIs to everything, you can say, “Okay, here is an API that the agent can use. The agent can build the entire network.”

A VPN protocol is merely a means of accessing that area. Within it, you can build a whole mesh network, whether you call it a “closed ecosystem,” a “parallel internet,” or whatever else.

There are 196 different domains that do not exist on the internet. You can process all kinds of tasks—registering domains, leasing IP addresses, leasing mesh-network or public addresses, and creating policies—in milliseconds. The inside is a completely different ecosystem.

Furthermore, we were able to develop a working P2P application by using that system. All app-based functions, such as phone calls, video calls, and chatting, are executed through the mesh network, and all the data is encrypted. No information such as phone numbers, email addresses, or names is exposed. It is a truly amazing thing.

Joel de la Garza

This is because both of us are quite well-versed in security. As you know, I have been told countless times that when having personal conversations, I should never do so where there are batteries or electrical signals.

So what you are saying is that they created a temporary method that allows people to connect and chat without leaving any records, right?

Barrett Lyon

Yes. When creating an account, you have to prove your identity by solving a simple puzzle. Once you complete that, you receive a token, and that token is yours. You can change the token, or delete the account and create a new one.

Once you create an account, you can generate a certificate and share it with your friends. In reality, you do not realize that you are doing it. It just says “Invite Friend” and looks like a regular chat, but the users are actually exchanging encrypted information with each other. You also receive additional permissions.

In my opinion, the key lesson of PKI is that if you tell people “PKI,” it does not work properly. We need to abstract that layer. Actually, it is not PKI—it is private-key infrastructure. It is not a public key.

Let us assume that you and your friend decide, “Okay, let’s trust each other.” Then mobile phones can communicate directly with each other through the mesh network. Suddenly, cool file-transfer features with no file-size limits become possible.

The real problem lies with WhatsApp, Signal, iMessage, and Telegram. By the way, Telegram is a bit creepy. All these apps disguise themselves as though you are sending something directly to someone else. In reality, they send the file to a server, and that server allows someone else to retrieve it.

When you upload a file, you are actually uploading it to a server. The upload infrastructure is not always well distributed, and the speed can be slow. For example, when uploading files from one region to another within the United States, the upload speed can be slow.

Using our application solves all of these problems. No intermediary or server is needed at all. Your mobile phone acts as a server and sends files directly to your friend. It is fast and works very well.

Even 20 GB files can be transferred between branches through a private network, and the latency is very low. It has up to 3 to 4 levels of encryption applied.

Joel de la Garza

I see. It also has quantum mechanics-level security, and it is a really useful tool.

Barrett Lyon

Putting all of this together, it could be said that Doxnet is like a massive collection of tools for freedom of expression and freedom from surveillance.

Joel de la Garza

5. The FBI's trojan messaging app

Yes, we should talk about this part as well. That is exactly the interesting point. As you mentioned, Telegram is a bit spooky.

Barrett Lyon

I think all VPN services are like that. It is a bit of a stretch to say that all VPNs are like this, but many VPN services seem very creepy. I do not mean to criticize any specific company, but the example that resonates with me the most is something I saw in the news recently.

Organized criminals have been arrested worldwide. I heard that a few were arrested in Australia and the United States as well. It turned out that the FBI had created a secure messaging app and sold it exclusively to organized-crime groups.

These people said, “Do not trust Signal because the NSA uses it. This app is safe and has only 5 users.” That is what they said. Eventually, they were all indicted, and I think most of them are in prison now.

Joel de la Garza

So you saw these kinds of activities in the United States as well, right?

Barrett Lyon

If you search for VPNs in the App Store, you will probably find about 50 VPNs.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, most of them are overseas.

Barrett Lyon

Just because something is free does not mean it is.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that is correct. If you do not pay, you become the product. It means being eaten alive.

Barrett Lyon

The United States has excellent laws. We can use those laws to protect people. The dark net is based in the United States, but there is also a Swiss company responsible for European operations. Therefore, the operations of the 2 regions are separated. Other regions operate in this way as well.

Joel de la Garza

So in this kind of situation, corporate governance is actually important. Honestly, I am reluctant to have my data handed over to a company that does not talk about its ownership or its reason for existence, other than privacy protection.

Barrett Lyon

We consciously decided to be very transparent about what we do, the people involved, and why we made those decisions. This also helps to revitalize the community.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, I know that too. The thing is, there are suspicious VPN companies.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that is right. The funny thing is that we like talking about the state or intelligence agencies. Agencies like the CIA and the NSA all look cool, do they not? However, in reality, there is a much lower level of risk.

For example, during the early cryptocurrency craze, there were cases in which money was withdrawn from people’s accounts, and those people were using services located in other countries. It turned out that in some countries, national intelligence agencies and organized crime are intertwined. So I could see these things mixing together.

Joel de la Garza

When people look at VPN policies, they often say “no logging,” so the question arises: Whose servers are those? Are they owned by a famous VPN company, or are they leased? If they are leased, from whom did the company borrow them? How does it handle the data? What is its policy?

That raises a question.

Barrett Lyon

There is such a dark side to the VPN industry. Personally, it wasn't easy to learn about these aspects because I didn't have the capacity to quickly build infrastructure worldwide. What I eventually realized was that you cannot set policies if the equipment is not your own. It's just impossible.

The next policy layer is the telecommunications operators and interconnections beyond the cage. As you know, it took a tremendous amount of effort to resolve the hidden side of service-type bare metal. I think this is one of the big differences between us and many other people: We own the entire stack, from the software to the wiring and routing. Even all the AI components that run it are on our own hardware.

Joel de la Garza

6. Running a network with AI, no sysadmin

One of the funny things about when we first talked about this was that you were very distrustful of large-scale reasoning and AI providers. You built your own AI stack.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. GPUs are insufficient, and it's difficult to secure data-processing capabilities.

Joel de la Garza

Now everyone is using data centers. How were you able to accomplish all of this in just 6 months?

Barrett Lyon

It was done very efficiently. We have built 26 sites around the world so far, all equipped with a redundant routing system.

Joel de la Garza

How many employees does the company have? It seems there are about 12 people in total. Wow, that's really amazing.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. We have neither a network administrator nor a system administrator. Everything is handled by AI, and it's actually working very well because I understand the situation well. The good thing is that we don't have thousands of employees with access to our network.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that's right. It means that the impact within the corporate structure is very minimal. That's really impressive. There's a part that we don't often talk about because it makes us uncomfortable: the severity of insider threats.

Barrett Lyon

Yes.

Joel de la Garza

I would like to point out that the most serious cyberattacks are always related to insider threats. You're saying that using the agent you just mentioned can eliminate a significant portion of those risks, right?

Barrett Lyon

Yes. This system operates in a secure environment on its own and does not leak data to large AI companies. All data, such as contacts and inferences, is processed internally. Security is strict, and all equipment is monitored by cameras. No one accesses or touches the equipment without permission.

Joel de la Garza

Is there an agent that checks the camera footage?

Barrett Lyon

Strictly speaking, we don't verify it directly, but the camera company that produced the agent does.

Joel de la Garza

Ah, I see.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. An alarm sounds if movement is detected or suspicious circumstances are found. We even considered installing lasers at some locations.

Joel de la Garza

Just like Mission: Impossible. Why wouldn't it work? It looks like it would be fun.

Barrett Lyon

We need at least 1 cool data center to take people to, right?

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that's the only way to leave a deep impression on people. Places like the Switch data center in Las Vegas. There are also Jeeps equipped with .50-caliber machine guns. There should be something like that.

Barrett Lyon

I really like lasers, so I went ahead with this project anyway. Simply put, we even looked into the laser operating switch. I set it so that an alarm would go off if the laser beam was cut off. However, the problem was that we couldn't turn off the lights in the data center, so we wouldn't be able to see that amazing laser show.

There shouldn't be any dust, and no fine particles should be floating around.

Joel de la Garza

7. The data center misinformation campaign

Yes, things like talcum powder cannot be brought in. I don't like that kind of thing. Let's create smoke in the data center for a laser show.

Barrett Lyon

Another thing that drives me crazy is that people don't understand data centers at all.

Joel de la Garza

Ah, that's right. It's really ridiculous. You must have seen things like that in the mainstream media, right?

Barrett Lyon

Ah, yes. Like, “Data centers drink water.” That makes no sense. Data centers have existed for a very long time, and while water needs to be replenished when equipment breaks down and evaporation occurs, they don't operate without water.

Joel de la Garza

That's really amazing. If you were to rank the most impressive machines created by humans, commercial aircraft would probably be number 1, right?

Barrett Lyon

Second place would probably be data centers. It's a really incredibly sophisticated and closed system.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, although the data center itself looks like just an ordinary building.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. Another surprising thing is that there are sounds that have never been heard outside of a data center. It might be something like a horror movie, but I saw people watching the video and saying, “Look at that hell.” It turned out the audio in the video had been dubbed from an internal recording.

Joel de la Garza

I think people don't know it's fake because they aren't smart enough to notice.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that's right. It's contained within every data center. People are being manipulated because of these data centers.

Joel de la Garza

Isn't that surprising? I think that as time goes by, it will be revealed that all of this was manipulated by certain groups or interest organizations.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, but it is quite interesting to realize later, after understanding the situation, that people were completely wrong.

Joel de la Garza

You've visited over 20 data centers in the last few months, haven't you? Have you ever seen people protesting outside?

Barrett Lyon

No, I didn't see anything. Most data centers, especially large data center complexes like the one in Virginia, have nothing but a single rabbit in the field. There's just a large building and a spacious parking lot.

Joel de la Garza

But that area is one of the wealthiest counties in the United States thanks to the data center, isn't it?

Barrett Lyon

That's right, because jobs are created. The people working there aren't getting paid peanuts, and high-tech talent is also being drawn in.

Joel de la Garza

Infrastructure is important too. Infrastructure is essential to everything we do, isn't it?

Barrett Lyon

Yes.

Joel de la Garza

If you're near a data center, the internet speed is faster and various things work better. And while it may vary depending on the data center, the claim that data centers use water for drinking is entirely fabricated.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. There was a Switch data center near Reno, and they built a big lake there. So people think that the data center uses the lake water for drinking.

Joel de la Garza

Yes. The reality is that, for example, if the chiller breaks down and you have to drain all the water from a sealed system, you have to refill it.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. You have to put it in the loop.

Joel de la Garza

Yes.

Barrett Lyon

So, anyway, I work in a building like this, and I find conspiracy theorists quite interesting. It feels like a typical conspiracy theory, just like people who believe the moon landing was faked. However, I believe this is a very important turning point for the future of our country's technology and for society as a whole.

Joel de la Garza

It feels like this conversation was manipulated for some purpose. It seems very fabricated.

Barrett Lyon

In my opinion, the future of our technology depends on building this infrastructure now. If we weaken this infrastructure, we're making the wrong decision.

Joel de la Garza

You're making the wrong decision in your Instagram post.

Barrett Lyon

Ah, yes. It's the same with TikTok, right? Who knows where such content is created? Something like a ridiculous music video opposing data centers.

Joel de la Garza

8. Ad trackers know you better than your spouse

Yes. It seems like public opinion is being manipulated by things like that. This is the second reason. We talked about intelligence agencies or scary governments, didn't we? But now we're talking about a scheme to manipulate public opinion for commercial gain. That's exactly the second reason you created Docks, which is related to advertising.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. People think the NSA is incredibly sophisticated, but advertisers are probably far ahead of them.

Joel de la Garza

Now we can see that intelligence agencies are using data brokers and employing the techniques of advertising agencies.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that's why every app has a tracker. WhatsApp has dit.whatsapp.net. Even Apple has something called Apple Telemetry.

Joel de la Garza

Whether you call it telemetry or metadata, it can be called a tracking tool anyway. You can block it, but apps or most websites don't have problems because of telemetry data. The rest of the websites load normally.

Barrett Lyon

A certain controversial wealthy person said this to me: “So what? Nobody's going to know that I bought underwear at Target.com.”

Then I said, “Well, actually, it's not just 1 problem. Everything is a problem. If you combine all the tracking happening on every app or website you use, that data accumulates. Without knowing who stores it or where it's sold, when you aggregate all that data, they can tell you whether you drink coffee, what time you wake up in the morning, how much you earn, where you shop, and even how often you buy things.

“If you're facing childbirth, divorce, or other major life events, they might even find out before your spouse does.”

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that's right.

Barrett Lyon

Turning off those features isn't a problem at all. In fact, I prefer them to be turned off. I really hate that kind of tracking. Dismantling these tracking features is a crucial part of apps and networks. It's not just an app problem; it's a problem for the entire network.

Joel de la Garza

It's about getting rid of those things. It's about returning to an internet where you can connect with objects and create things, just like the old internet, without being monitored by advertisers, the government, or anyone else.

Barrett Lyon

However, I think we're currently standing at a really important turning point. coin-operated intelligent systems have appeared on a large scale, haven't they? We can deploy millions of units, and preventative measures are also possible. It's like the proverb that millions of monkeys are holding an infinite number of typewriters.

So we're facing a world with more telemetry data, where every action is tracked. If you combine intelligence with that, you can reach a truly terrifying conclusion.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, you can put all this information into the LLM (Local Lifecycle) and say, “Please tell me about this person.”

Barrett Lyon

You get the answer. I think you can do really effective targeting even against things like data centers, right?

Joel de la Garza

Yes. When you see large-scale movements happening systematically across multiple platforms, you think, “Oh, that’s pretty clever.”

Barrett Lyon

Yes. What people should be targeting isn’t data centers, but tracking systems. Life would be much easier if things like ad tracking really disappeared.

Joel de la Garza

Yes. The key is to revive the vibe the internet used to have and then see how far we can develop that. If we utilize larger resources, we could create protocols that don’t exist yet.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that’s right. The reason the internet succeeded was because it was free.

Joel de la Garza

Thank you for trying to make it free again.

Barrett Lyon

I tried, but you still have to pay me.

Joel de la Garza

9. Prolexic, Russian hackers, and MoMA

Yes, that’s right. Just kidding. That’s cool. I don’t know if you know this, but we met a long time ago. I dug through some old files, and it turns out you did a lot of work related to DDoS bots starting in the early 2000s. So I’m going to drive up the stock price.

There was TFN, TFN2K, and, of course, large-scale DDoS (Denial of Service) attacks. You took the lead in developing solutions to prevent such attacks at Prolexic, didn’t you? How did you get started?

Barrett Lyon

In fact, it goes back to the dark net era. My friends attacked my server when I was in high school, so I had to research better ways to protect the server—techniques and tricks to survive DDoS attacks. I started organizing ways to survive, and I presented them at SANS, which ended up in Google search results.

From then on, people started contacting me. Then I started dealing with real cybercrimes: threats, for example, involving attacks on 2 watch companies during the Christmas sale. There were also cases where all the gambling sites were paralyzed right before the Super Bowl started.

As such incidents became increasingly serious, I established a company to protect businesses from these attacks. In my opinion, a large-scale system was needed. We needed the largest and most expensive equipment, but not everyone could afford it, so we created it as a kind of rental service—one of the first cloud services.

It was quite successful and still exists. I mean, Akamai Prolexic.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that’s correct. They even kept the name exactly the same.

Barrett Lyon

It’s a very rare case. Later, I created DefenseNet, which became F5 Silverline. In addition to that, I worked on several other projects.

I was very interested in large-scale systems and bandwidth, so I founded a company called BitGravity, which was one of the video-centric CDNs. It was specialized for transferring large files and large objects. We secured a lot of really good customers in the beginning. People understood our service, and we also developed many technologies to reduce costs.

It was something people didn’t know, but when you pressed the play button, a progressive file would be downloaded and transmitted before everything was finished. There were media-management features of this kind, but scrolling to the middle of the video just ended up wasting bandwidth.

Yes, that’s right. Besides, it was expensive, so we made all sorts of cool things related to video.

Joel de la Garza

Well, speaking of building a new network for consumers, it actually includes some features for bots as well.

Barrett Lyon

Actually, it contains a lot of network-related elements. I enjoy building large-scale infrastructure, so this field suits my aptitude perfectly. I like building scalable systems.

However, now we’ve changed direction from being for companies to being for people. I haven’t seen many attempts like this done properly yet. I think it will be interesting to see how people adapt.

Joel de la Garza

The more interesting point is that your network could be subject to DDoS attacks. You’re probably ready, right?

Barrett Lyon

Although it’s an attack coming from the internet, it’s someone blindly approaching and attacking. I started using my network internally, but I had to deal with those stupid people.

Joel de la Garza

Yes. However, the truth is that even if privacy is guaranteed, laws exist, and we must obey them as much as possible.

There’s another interesting point I learned from talking with you for a few years: your work has been exhibited at MoMA.

Barrett Lyon

Yes. 2 pieces are on display as part of the permanent collection. It was a university project. I majored in philosophy.

It might sound strange, but I studied philosophy. I studied things like aesthetics and some other subjects, but most of it was theoretical AI.

Joel de la Garza

Wow, I finally understand a philosophy degree.

Barrett Lyon

Really? It was very helpful. The reason I started mapping the network was because I was in the middle of a penetration test as a penetration tester. It involves hacking another company, so it’s ethical hacking.

I thought the easiest way to start was to look inside the company. You create a network diagram to figure out where everything is, how it works, and what needs to be where. I started automating that.

Then, one day at lunchtime, I made a bet with my friends that I could map the entire internet using the same technology. It started with a $50 bet, and I was almost certain I would lose. But I was hit by a car while riding my bicycle.

I couldn’t walk. Suddenly, life slowed down so much that I sat down and started coding, and that became the Opte project. That project went on to tour not only at MoMA but also at places like the Boston Museum of Science and many other locations around the world.

I also made an animation. It’s a really great project. It received a lot of attention not simply because it looked cool, but because the video contained truly interesting history. All sorts of things happen, such as companies going bankrupt and collapsing.

Luckily, I had the opportunity to talk with Vint Cerf, and it was really great to be able to ask him my questions directly.

Joel de la Garza

That’s really cool. Now you’ve accomplished the 2 hardest things in the world. One is founding a successful IT company, and the other is becoming a successful artist. Becoming a successful artist is probably much harder than starting an IT company.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that’s right. Actually, I felt a bit strange. I went to the opening at MoMA, and it was like a huge party.

I was also one of the participating artists, and my work was displayed in a new exhibition, which was a really wonderful experience. There was a DJ, we drank alcohol, and curators came too. I was able to look around a few other interesting places owned by MoMA, and it was a really wonderful experience.

But the next day, I felt like I had fake syndrome. I was really depressed. I thought, “Wow, will I ever feel like an artist again? This was really just a coincidence.”

I was able to have that experience again, though it was a really strange and surreal moment. I’m probably the only person who can say that in the technology field.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, it’s interesting.

Barrett Lyon

I have many artist friends who are much more talented than me, and they all ask, “How did you get into MoMA?”

Joel de la Garza

Yes, I’m curious how this happened. Plus, it’s really cool that it was included in the permanent collection.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, it’s 1 in hundreds or thousands. Sometimes I forget. I even forgot about the book.

Joel de la Garza

That’s right. We haven’t talked about the book yet. Do you want to talk about it?

Barrett Lyon

Dealing with that story is fine. I guess I should add this to the list of absurd stories. I keep forgetting that I have it, too.

Recently, there’s been an AI-based webcam that monitors boats in Miami. It operates 24 hours a day. I’ve had it installed for almost a year, and there’s a small chat community there, too.

One of them found out who I was and not long ago said, “I just finished reading the book about you.” That’s what they said.

So I said, “What did you say?”

“What do you mean?”

“Ah, right. You figured it out.”

Then I said, “So, is that book about you, and what is it about?”

I think it’s about the beginning of Prolexic and tracking down Russian cybercriminals. In particular, there were a few former employees who severely threatened and harmed our clients. We couldn’t take it anymore and decided, “This can’t go on like this.”

We ruined Christmas because of customer service and network outages, but these people were real criminals. They weren’t just simple hackers. They engaged in human trafficking and drug smuggling and committed other crimes as a side job. They were doing something suspicious.

They were real criminals. I think they were sentenced to about 8 years of hard labor and went to prison. I don’t know what happened after that, but we went to Russia and lost our way. We were in Moscow for a while, and we detected some very interesting signals.

Then it was, “We have to leave right now.”

So we left. The entire book is a story covering everything that happened during that time. The really strange thing is that, at the time, it all seemed ordinary, but looking back, I think, “Wow, it was really chaotic.”

Joel de la Garza

That’s right. As I say, every time we talk, we hear a new story. Let’s stop talking about Burning Man. We could make a whole episode out of just that.

When was the first Burning Man?

Barrett Lyon

It’s next week.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, this weekend. Are you going again this year?

Barrett Lyon

Yes.

Joel de la Garza

That’s cool.

Barrett Lyon

It’s probably the 14th year. It’s about that long. I don’t remember exactly. I couldn’t go a few times because of COVID, so I don’t remember which ones I skipped.

Joel de la Garza

And you have a famous car, right?

Barrett Lyon

Yes, my partner has a famous car. Pablo made the Mind Warrior, and we built Mind Warrior Camp. We were partners in that crazy project for a while, and that car went from just a fun project into a global phenomenon.

People even paid to go see it. It’s really amazing. But so many things happened. What I was thinking this morning is that when you pour your passion into something, that passion creates an aura around you, and others feel it too. We were really passionate about that project, and I think that inspired a lot of people, leading us to do similar interesting projects.

Joel de la Garza

We aren’t going to Playa this year.

Barrett Lyon

Oh, you’re not going?

Joel de la Garza

Oh, it’s over. Are you going to do a laser show?

Barrett Lyon

No.

Joel de la Garza

Wow, okay.

Barrett Lyon

No. There will be something, but not mine. Pablo is bringing some cool artwork. The 2 pieces he’s bringing this year are going to be really cool.

Joel de la Garza

That’s cool.

Barrett Lyon

But there are no more mobile, super-powerful sound stages. They’re gone now.

Joel de la Garza

Starlink internet access is available now. What’s the atmosphere like?

Barrett Lyon

Actually, you could argue with that, but maybe—I suppose so. I think it’s really helpful for organizing the camp, or for things like when the art car runs out of water, because it allows for communication.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, that’s right. We always carry high-powered Motorola walkie-talkies.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, that’s correct. They even use shortwave broadcasting.

Joel de la Garza

Having a walkie-talkie is fun, and it brings back childhood memories. After all, it is a means of communication. It helps a lot when finding things or organizing.

Barrett Lyon

It also reduces the long wait times at the entrance.

Joel de la Garza

Yes. However, using a walkie-talkie just to sit and watch movies isn’t appropriate. You aren’t going to Burning Man to just spend time watching Netflix, are you?

Barrett Lyon

Absolutely not. If you use it for purposes other than local communication, that might be the wrong way to use it. But things have changed a lot.

Joel de la Garza

Yes, yes. That’s cool. As you said, it seems that chasing your passion leads to amazing discoveries. You are clearly someone who always chases your passion.

Thank you so much for visiting.

Barrett Lyon

I am very satisfied with using docs.net, and thank you for creating it. It brings back the atmosphere of the old internet.

Joel de la Garza

It’s great to be able to do this.

Barrett Lyon

Yes, this is just the beginning, and thank you for trusting me so that we can build this together.