[BidClub_]
iConnections · TomorrowX Summit · · 16 min

Retail, AI and the American Dream | Gavin Baker, Antonio Gracias & Ron Biscardi | TomorrowX Summit

Gavin BakerAntonio GraciasRon BiscardiSara Eisen

EquitiesSemisInvesting
YouTube ↗
TL;DR
  • Baker calls retail “the most powerful force in the market.” His catalyst was a semiconductor capital equipment stock rising 7% despite a prestigious bank downgrading it to strong sell and sharply cutting its price target; he would normally expect a 5–10% drop. He says a line by his friend Citrini, after the stock was put in a Substack/X basket, moved the market more than the bank’s call. Baker sees this as part of six or seven years of investing becoming more democratic.
  • TomorrowX aims to connect retail investors with management teams, including private companies. Baker highlights over 100 private companies, almost all with CEOs, and over 1,000 scholarships for constructive X, Substack and Reddit contributors. Biscardi reports over 1,000 sign-ups in three days and predicts “a sold-out stadium next year.”
  • Baker says equities broadly trade at 10-, 15- and sometimes 20-year low valuation multiples, which he reads as a market bet on peak spending. If AI keeps becoming “more economically useful” and token-demand elasticity stays positive, he sees a possible alternative to telecom’s spending spike and subsequent underinvestment. His railroad analogy is roughly 60 years of investment at a comparable share of GDP, with nineteenth-century estimates necessarily imprecise.
  • Baker favors “slower, smoother for longer,” with constraints tempering overbuilding. He points to higher real rates, widening spreads and wafer shortages, while acknowledging his view that anything slowing the buildout helps has been challenged over the past six or seven weeks. He says “we’re certainly not in a bubble right now,” and flags Nvidia earnings “tonight” and the Anthropic IPO, “I believe tomorrow.”
  • Gracias’s AI optimism leaves room for bad outcomes. On jobs and existential risk, he says, “It could be great. It could be terrible.” He urges compassion for justified anxiety and showing people the future being built, aiming to move them from a “P(doom) state” to a “P(boom) state.”
  • Gracias sees creativity alongside productivity as AI’s broader promise. He points to caregivers and doctors gaining time with patients, scientific discoveries and more time at home. His example is making a music video in three hours, despite considering himself uncreative: “Human creativity is being unleashed.”
Digest · the substance, structured for research

1. Retail research can overpower a bank downgrade

  • Baker recalls a semiconductor capital equipment stock rising 7% after a prestigious bank downgraded it to strong sell, sharply cut its price target and said the company would miss earnings. He would normally expect a 5–10% drop.
  • He says a Substack and X account, along with his friend Citrini, had put the stock in a basket and written a line about it; Baker says Citrini’s line moved the market more than the bank’s call. This crystallized his view that retail is “the most powerful force in the market,” after six or seven years of investing becoming more democratic.
  • Baker sees an opportunity to connect the online accounts retail relies on with management teams and help retail investors become better informed.

2. Private-company access extends the democratization

  • Baker highlights over 100 private companies at the event, almost all with CEOs, and over 1,000 scholarships for constructive and active X, Substack and Reddit contributors.
  • Biscardi describes iConnections’ move from institutional capital introduction into retail as a way to bring everyday investors an institutional-grade event and access they would not normally get at a banking conference.
  • Biscardi reports over 1,000 sign-ups in three days, says awareness is the main challenge, and predicts “a sold-out stadium next year.”

3. Optimism must acknowledge what Americans fear

  • Gracias says median income is $87,500 a year and poverty is about 10%, an all-time low, while the median hourly wage is about $1.50 an hour and remains where it was before COVID. He says many Americans are anxious about AI and asks how to help them feel positive about it.
  • Eisen raises concerns about jobs and existential risk. Gracias says, “It could be great. It could be terrible,” and urges “basic compassion and understanding” for people who cannot see what lies beyond the AI “event horizon.”
  • He wants the industry to help people see the future it is creating: “Is it Star Trek? It is Star Trek if we make it Star Trek.” His aim is to move people from a “P(doom) state” to a “P(boom) state.”

4. Creativity broadens the promise beyond productivity

  • Gracias points to caregivers and doctors gaining time with patients, scientific discoveries, less commuting and more time at home as ways AI could improve ordinary lives.
  • He made a music video in three hours using separate video, editing and music applications, despite calling himself the least creative guy possible. He presents it as a small example of how someone like him can make something enjoyable, and says AI is unleashing human creativity as well as productivity.

5. Useful AI and constrained supply could prolong spending

  • Baker says equities broadly have 10-, 15- and, in some cases, 20-year low valuation multiples. He reads the market as saying spending is at its peak. A telecom-style buildout followed by underused assets and prolonged underinvestment “would be very painful” for bulls.
  • If AI keeps becoming more economically useful and token-demand elasticity remains positive, he sees a possible railroad-style buildout: roughly 60 years at a comparable share of GDP. He cautions against false precision in estimating nineteenth-century GDP.
  • Baker says value could be redistributed among parts of the “five-layer cake”: land, power, shell and chip categories, including compute, networking, memory and storage. If AI’s economic usefulness continues to grow, he expects compute’s value to rise.
  • His preference is “slower, smoother for longer.” He says higher interest rates and real rates, widening spreads and wafer shortages are slowing the buildout; he argues that a world where TSMC, Taiwan Semi, Micron, Samsung and SK Hynix expanded capacity by 200% would surely overbuild, consistent with what he describes as 400 years of capitalism’s history. He says that if companies slow down next year and cut numbers roughly in line with consensus, that could help avoid a sharp spike and crash.
  • Baker says “we’re certainly not in a bubble right now.” He flags Nvidia earnings “tonight” and the Anthropic IPO, “I believe tomorrow,” as major near-term events.
Full transcript
Sara Eisen

Welcome. I’m so honored to be here. I’m Sara Eisen from CNBC, with the fabulous hosts of today’s TomorrowX. I’m glad to see everybody out here.

Gavin, this was an idea you started on X, and now we’re in a basketball stadium. It’s amazing to see. I just want to say thank you to everyone who worked so hard to make this a reality.

Gavin Baker

It came together quickly, and I’m kind of amazed that it looks so good. I’d like to thank everyone for coming. Hopefully it’s a great event. We want to make it better every year, so if you have feedback, tell us.

Sara Eisen

Tell us about how it came about. That was in January, right? I think we can date it specifically.

1. One line that beat a bank downgrade

Gavin Baker

There was a day when a bulge-bracket, very prestigious investment bank downgraded a semiconductor capital equipment stock to a strong sell. Normally, you’d expect the stock to be down 5% or 10% that day. They massively slashed the price target and said the company was going to miss earnings. Instead, the stock was up 7%.

2. Retail is the most powerful force in the market

The reason was that a Substack and an X account, and a friend of mine named Citrini, had put it in a basket and written one line about it. One line from Citrini moved the market much more than this bulge-bracket investment bank. That really crystallized something for me, because I’m very active on X, as you know. I know most of the people on X, and over the last 6 or 7 years I’ve observed this amazing democratization of investing.

I think retail is now the most powerful force in the market. I think that’s good. Anything that democratizes anything is good. For me, there was an opportunity to bridge the gap between these accounts—these Reddits, these Substacks—that really seem to move the markets and that retail relies on, and management teams. There was a way to help retail be more informed and create a bridge between retail and management teams. I thought that was something good for the world, and that was exciting for me.

3. Telling the truth about AI for ordinary Americans

All credit to Antonio and his partner, Juan [?]. I think it was Juan; I don’t remember if it was Juan or Antonio. They pointed out that in China, everyone is overwhelmingly positive on AI, while in America, people are very scared of AI. This isn’t intended to pump AI stocks; it has nothing to do with the stock market. I don’t think that fear is good.

Antonio and Juan really suggested asking each company several questions about how AI was making the lives of ordinary Americans better. A great line from the Bible is, “The truth shall set you free,” but it can only set you free if you tell the truth. The AI industry needs to tell the truth about how AI is and can be good for ordinary Americans. That’s going to be a big part of this, too.

Sara Eisen

I love both of those ideas. The media has a role to play on that front, too. We’ve been trying to tell the story of what’s actually happening in people’s lives because of AI, and to democratize information. We do that, too.

4. An institutional-grade event for everyday investors

So then Ron gets involved, right? iConnections. This is different from what you typically do for an institutional crowd.

Ron Biscardi

It’s very different. iConnections is the largest capital introduction platform in the institutional world. We deal with sovereign wealth funds, endowments, and foundations. We had never really done anything in retail.

I think it was the same day Gavin was describing: I got a call from these guys, and it was, “Hey, we’ve decided we want to do an event, and we’d like some help putting it together.” iConnections is very good at the technology that supports events and brings people together. We loved the idea that we could make a push into the retail market, take all of our relationships and expertise, and create a high-quality, institutional-grade event in a much bigger setting, making it available to everyday investors—the X crowd who normally wouldn’t get to a banking conference. We were super excited to do it.

Truthfully, I also loved the theme of helping everyday Americans embrace AI and finding ways for AI to benefit them and really revitalize the American dream. When Juan said that on one of our calls, it really resonated with me. At iConnections, and personally, I use AI every day in so many amazing ways. I’m a very big proponent of it. I think a big point of this conference is to spread the positive side of this message, which I just don’t think is getting a fair hearing.

Sara Eisen

And spread it in a setting that isn’t a hotel ballroom, as some of those bank conferences are. I know the mission was really critical for you to hear. Tell us about what you had envisioned.

5. Reviving the American dream

Antonio Gracias

First, let me thank Gavin and Ron. I wouldn’t be here without them. It was Gavin’s idea, and Ron executed it super well. We talked to Gavin about this: “Hey, we’d like to invite you to do this as his partner.” Thank you, Gavin. We were already firm on it. We said, “Okay, we’d like to do this. There’s a mission that really matters. We can do this mission together about reviving the American dream.”

The reality is, Americans have been doing quite well. Median income is $87,500 a year. Poverty rates are at an all-time low, about 10%. But the median hourly wage is about $1.50 an hour. It’s stuck right where it was pre-COVID. There are many people in America who are feeling anxious about AI. It’s not helping them in the way they want it to. But there’s an event horizon coming up, and the question is: How do we get the rest of America to feel positive about what’s happening in AI?

6. From P doom to P boom

If you look at prior periods in human history, when you had this kind of technological change at a time when humans had the capacity to do more things, you saw them in the video here, right? That’s ancient Athens in the time of Aristotle, Rome, the Renaissance. These were all built on human misery.

This is a period when you’re going to have an unleashing of human creativity and creativity built on human well-being. We’re talking about AI. You’re working on AI with caregivers, right? With doctors, giving them more time with patients; with scientific discoveries; and with more time at home because you have less time commuting and less time at work. This is a moment when, if we unleash American creativity and productivity, we can all live a lot better. Everybody, from the most humble person to the people in this audience, can live a lot better.

We want to spread that message to get people out of a sort of P(doom) state and into a P(boom) state. It’s hard to be happy if you’re afraid or anxious, and we want people to know that there’s a great future out there. We just have to make it happen. The things we feel and believe turn into the things that happen in reality. We’re hoping to change the conception of what’s possible for all of America.

7. Star Trek or Terminator?

Sara Eisen

You said that it’s understandable and justified that there are fears around it: jobs, existential risk. How do you think the industry should manage those very real concerns while getting people on board with adoption and helping them better their lives?

Antonio Gracias

I think we start with basic compassion and understanding. We explain to people, “Look, we understand you’re anxious.” If an event horizon is like a dark piece of glass, it’s hard to see past it. When you can’t see what’s coming, it’s right to be anxious. When you turn the lights on, you can see into the darkness. It could be great; it could be terrible. It’s possible. I wouldn’t say it’s not possible. It is possible.

The things we think and feel in life, we create; we manifest them. So what I’d say is that the industry has to help people see the future we’re creating. Is it Star Trek? It is Star Trek if we make it Star Trek. That’s why we’re here: to help people see that future. Whether you’re a student in the audience, a professional investor, or a retail investor, when you go home, how you behave, how you use it, and how you bring it into your life will change your creativity and productivity, the time you have with your family, and the way you enjoy life.

8. Cars fly and rockets land

I made a music video. Anyone who knows me knows that’s a joke. I’m the least creative guy possible. It was super fun for me. It took me 3 hours.

Sara Eisen

You made a music video?

Antonio Gracias

I actually made a music video. I used it. Well, actually, I made music, so I used it. I’m not trying to use a robot. It signed me into 3 different applications: one for video, one for editing, and one for music. I made some music, made the video, put it all together, and it was super cool.

9. What Gavin asks management teams

I think this is a small example of how a guy like me, who’s not creative in this way at all, can do something cool that I enjoy. That’s the message I give people here: creativity in prior booms. In our lifetime, we’ve seen productivity growth a lot. This isn’t just productivity. This is actually creativity, too. Human creativity is being unleashed, and we’re seeing it. I think we’ve never seen more companies in our careers.

10. Railroad or telecom? The AI buildout

Antonio Gracias

I can say that confidently. It’s being unleashed across the system, across the economy. In the last month, we’ve seen cars fly and rockets land. If that’s not the future, what is? That is the future. And it’s bringing that home to every individual in America, no matter where they sit on the economic spectrum, enabling them to make their lives better with this technology.

Sara Eisen

So, Gavin, from an investor standpoint, that’s good perspective on America. You said a big part of this is about access to the CEOs and leaders building and financing the AI revolution. You’re a prolific investor. What sort of questions are you asking management right now to determine whether to double down?

Gavin Baker

I think the most important thing is that equities are, broadly speaking, at 10-, 15-, in some cases, 20-year low valuation multiples. The stock market is basically saying we’re at peak spending. There’s a question of whether this is going to be a buildout like the telecom buildout, where there was a huge spike and then we weren’t really using the assets we’d put in the ground. Then you had a long period of underinvestment, which would be very painful for anyone in this room who’s bullish.

Or is this technology continuing to get more economically useful? Is the elasticity of token demand still positive? If the answers to those questions are yes, then I think there’s a world where this buildout is much more like the railroad buildout. The railroad buildout lasted for 60 years at a roughly comparable percentage of GDP to where we are today. We can’t be precise about GDP in the 19th century, so let’s not pretend to have false precision.

The value is probably redistributed among different parts of the five-layer cake: land, power, shell, and different kinds of chips—compute versus networking versus memory and storage. If this buildout continues because artificial intelligence keeps getting more economically useful, then you’d think the value of compute will continue to rise.

11. The future of TomorrowX

My view has always been—and it’s certainly been challenged in the last 6 or 7 weeks—that anything that slows this down is good. Imagine if we were living in a world where TSMC, Taiwan Semi, Micron, Samsung, and SK Hynix were expanding capacity by 200%. We’d for sure get an overbuild. That’s the history of the last literally 400 years of capitalism. But because we actually have higher interest rates, higher real rates, widening spreads, and a shortage of wafers, we’re slowing this down. Ironically, if we do slow down a little bit next year, and they cut their numbers basically in line with consensus, I just think we want slower for longer, slower, smoother for longer, as opposed to a really sharp spike and then a crash. The one thing no one wants is a bubble. That would be terrible. We’re certainly not in a bubble right now.

We’re going to turn over 2 or 3 really big cards this week, with Nvidia earnings tonight and the Anthropic IPO, I believe, tomorrow. Those are big cards to turn over. So, Ron, how big can this get? What are your plans for the future of TomorrowX?

12. Opening up 100+ private companies

Ron Biscardi

Oh, for sure we’re going to fill this place next year. This will be a sold-out stadium next year. I think we signed up over 1,000 people in the last 3 days. Our challenge whenever you do an event in a short time frame is just getting the word out.

Gavin and Antonio have attracted the best CEOs in the world of AI to this event. They didn’t have much of a challenge getting those people to come and participate. It’s just building awareness. Having you here, Sara, will definitely help us build awareness. Thank you, you and CNBC, for being here.

This will be something we do every year. And just on the CEOs—and a lot of these came from Antonio and Dalla—something else that was important to me in terms of democratizing investing and equalizing access to information is that there are a lot of conferences institutional investors can go to and see private companies. These private companies are giant companies, and retail investors and a lot of these Substacks and X accounts have very little visibility into them. That was something else that was important to me.

How many private companies do we have here? Over 100. We have over 100 private companies here, almost all with CEOs. Many of them are doing meetings. We gave out over 1,000 scholarships to people who have X accounts and are constructive and active contributors, Substacks, and Reddits. I hope shining a light on some of these private companies also helps educate and democratize the audience.

Sara Eisen

Thank you, guys. I’m excited to be here. We’re doing our show from here, and we’re excited for all the onstage opportunities. Congratulations.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Thank you, Mayor.