Bawdy: ZEC vs XMR, Dark Markets, Monero's Bull Case and More | TG Podcast
Bawdy’s bull case is adoption before narrative: XMR’s rise from roughly $200 through $250-$300 largely preceded the broader privacy rally, with Monero near $400 at recording. He credits default privacy, organic spending, and a circular economy rather than exchange-driven speculation. That makes XMR less prone to “memecoin kind of pumps,” but, in his view, gives it a harder price floor and long-term durability.
Monero’s key advantage is that privacy is mandatory and usable without operational gymnastics. Amounts are hidden with Bulletproofs, senders with 16-member ring signatures, recipients with stealth addresses, and network origins with Dandelion++; Bawdy says Bitcoin pushed him toward XMR because private spending otherwise required managing mixes, outputs, Tor, and mistakes. For ordinary payments, “you don’t have to think about it.”
Full-chain membership proofs, expected by Bawdy in six to nine months, are meant to close Monero’s largest known privacy gap. Today Zcash has the stronger anonymity-set design because shielded transactions sign over the pool’s entire output set, while Monero uses rings of 16. FCMP would give Monero a comparable full-set approach that Bawdy says is smaller, faster, and batch-verifiable, though high-threat users will still face metadata and heuristic risks.
The usage comparison, as Bawdy presents it, overwhelmingly favors XMR over shielded ZEC. Monero has reportedly sustained 20,000-30,000 daily private transactions for years and often ranks first or second wherever it is offered beside BTC, ETH, LTC, or USDT; he estimates historical shielded Zcash activity at roughly 100 transactions a day or fewer, while acknowledging he did not know the current figure. His most tangible evidence is commerce: VPNs, servers, AI access, gift cards, and even “freeze-dried beef for Monero.”
The alleged Monero “hostile takeover” was neither a 51% attack nor a successful capture of the network. Bawdy says Qubic reached at most 33% of hash power by paying miners in its token at roughly twice the normal XMR reward, enabling five-to-30-minute reorganizations before losing money and retreating as its token fell. The episode exposed a real selfish-mining vulnerability, but also suggested that roughly two-thirds of Monero’s CPU-mining base was apparently “not for sale” even at 2x rewards.
Exchange exclusion is both a distribution constraint and part of the decentralization thesis. Kraken remains an accessible U.S. spot venue outside New York, while wallets, atomic swaps, RetoSwap, Trocador, and instant-swap aggregators help users “route around” delistings; XMR perpetuals remain available on venues including Binance, Bybit, dYdX, and GTrade. With no foundation, premine, dev tax, or corporate entity, development instead depends on community crowdfunding.
Bawdy rejects both winner-take-all maximalism and the claim that privacy is mainly for criminals. He now regards Zcash’s cryptography as credible after years of review, but criticizes its implementation and limited shielded usage; he argues Monero also protects users from surveillance, tainted-coin accusations, and involuntary disclosure. Thread Guy frames privacy as an extension of freedom of expression: “Silence itself is expression,” and every withheld piece of data is “a little bit of your freedom, of your sovereignty, that you’ve taken back.”
1. Monero emerged as privacy-first money without a corporate sponsor
Bawdy traces the problem to Bitcoin’s beginning: Hal Finney was already seeking stronger privacy on day 11, but more than a decade of experience showed that optional tools were not equivalent to privacy “developed from the ground up.”
Monero launched in 2014 without a known founder, premine, dev tax, foundation, or corporate entity. After the pseudonymous Thankful_for_today proposed changes the community rejected, contributors forked the pre-launch BitMonero repository, renamed it Monero, and started fresh.
Its animating premise is fungibility: one unit should not carry a traceable history that changes its acceptability. As Bawdy put it, nobody asks which $100 bill belonged to whom—“they all have cocaine on it.”
2. Default privacy removes the operational burden that made Bitcoin cumbersome
Bawdy’s conversion came from trying to spend Bitcoin privately: mixing coins, managing outputs, using Tor, and avoiding address-linking errors became “way too much.” His solution was to hold XMR and swap it into another asset only when a recipient would not accept Monero.
Monero hides amounts using Bulletproofs, which Bawdy described as quantum-resistant and “perfectly blinding.” Protecting amounts matters because distinctive payment sizes can become metadata for reconstructing a user’s activity.
Senders currently hide among rings of 16 historical outputs; recipients use stealth addresses, generating unlinkable destinations for every payment. Dandelion++ adds default IP obfuscation, though Bawdy still recommends a VPN or Tor when the threat model warrants it.
His hedge is important: neither Monero nor Zcash is immune to off-chain metadata, behavioral heuristics, or poor operational security. Default Monero is “good enough” for ordinary purchases and donations; darknet vendors and similarly exposed users still need to study the edge cases.
3. FCMP would close the technical gap where Zcash is stronger
Bawdy concedes that Zcash is technically better at sender anonymity today: shielded transactions can sign over the pool’s entire output set, whereas Monero’s ring design exposes a smaller candidate set that adversaries might reduce through heuristics.
That was originally a conservative engineering choice. In 2014, zk-SNARKs were “new moon math,” expensive to run, and understood by very few people; Monero chose older, reviewed primitives that ordinary hardware could support, later expanding rings from three to 11 and then 16.
Full-chain membership proofs are intended to replace that compromise. Bawdy expected FCMP in six to nine months and said the implementation would be somewhat faster and smaller than Zcash’s, with batch verification also possible: the benefit of waiting is that Monero can “choose the best implementation” after the mathematics matures.
4. Actual spending, not cryptographic novelty, separates XMR from ZEC
Across services where Bawdy has seen XMR and ZEC offered together, Monero receives far more usage while Zcash is often “a fraction of a percent.” He reports 20,000-30,000 Monero transactions daily for years, all private by default, versus historically around 100 or fewer daily shielded Zcash transactions.
The circular economy includes VPNs, servers, donations, gift cards, Coincards-funded Airbnb purchases, NanoGPT access, and peer-to-peer listings on XMRBazaar. His deliberately mundane example—buying freeze-dried beef—underscores that the community is mostly ordinary users, not “darknet market extraordinaires.”
Bawdy was candid about the comparison’s limit: he has barely tried to spend Zcash and was unsure whether NanoGPT currently accepts it. His claim rests on observed payment shares and shielded activity, not a comprehensive audit of ZEC merchants.
5. Qubic exposed selfish-mining risk but never captured Monero
The attack drew on the “selfish mining” strategy described by researchers Eyal and Sirer: a miner withholds a discovered block and privately attempts to extend it, exploiting normal streaks in proof-of-work block discovery.
By its own account, Qubic peaked around 33% of Monero hash power, not 51%. It subsidized miners with Qubic tokens worth roughly twice the ordinary XMR mining reward and achieved short reorganizations lasting approximately five to 30 minutes, but Bawdy says the campaign lost money and faded after Qubic’s price fell.
Bawdy spent six weeks building a simulator that can model a year of Monero blocks in roughly 40 seconds, hoping to test countermeasures without overlooking side effects. Calling himself only an “advanced pleb,” he expects deliberate research rather than a rushed fix and suggested a solution might arrive next year.
6. Delistings constrained access without extinguishing the market
Bawdy declined to present exchange pressure as a proven conspiracy, though he suspects Monero’s lack of a premine meant exchanges never received the financial inducements available from projects that distributed tokens to them. Kraken, backed early by Jesse Powell, still offers XMR in much of the United States but delisted it in Europe and never obtained New York’s BitLicense with Monero listed.
The community’s response was to “route around” centralized venues through Bitcoin-XMR atomic swaps, RetoSwap, wallet integrations, and aggregators such as Trocador and OrangeFren. Bawdy claims users can move roughly $10,000-$50,000 through instant swaps in about 30 minutes without much difficulty.
For simpler onboarding, he recommends Cake Wallet, whose built-in swaps can convert assets including BTC, ETH, and SOL into XMR; desktop users can download software or run a node through GetMonero.org. Spot access is limited, but XMR/USDT perpetuals remain tradable on several large derivatives venues.
Development uses the Community Crowdfunding System rather than corporate revenue. Luke Parker’s FCMP proposal was funded “practically overnight,” illustrating the thesis: there is no foundation whose corporate status a government can pressure, and many contributors are anonymous.
7. The bull case is durable utility, not one privacy coin ruling them all
Bawdy says XMR’s early move toward $250-$300 happened before the broader privacy frenzy took hold. He calls Monero the best-performing coin of the 2022 bear market and argues that real spending, limited perpetuals speculation, and committed holders create stability even when Binance and European Kraken users lose spot access.
His pushback on maximalism is historical: gold, silver, copper, scrip, and roughly 200 fiat currencies have coexisted because different monies serve different purposes. Monero need not defeat Bitcoin, Zcash, or stablecoins; he wants its potential maximized within the use cases it can realistically serve.
He has also changed his view of Zcash. Years of scrutiny moved its cryptography from dubious “moon math” to “pretty good tech”; his complaint is implementation and adoption, while Monero’s community developed “a natural immunity” to laser-eyed maximalism after watching Bitcoin’s 2017 civil war.
Bawdy argues that transparent coins can implicate innocent holders through tainted transaction histories, while Monero can support voluntary transparency through shared view keys.
Thread Guy frames privacy more broadly as control over disclosure and an extension of freedom of expression. His practical prescription is incremental—VPNs, cookie blocking, better browsers, and other privacy tools—because every small denial of surveillance data is “like a little savings account” of freedom and sovereignty.