What It Means to Be a “Real” Entrepreneur | Michael Rubin, Fanatics
- Fanatics is using its existing sports audience to build a consumer platform, with Rubin expecting $14 billion in revenue and 40% or more organic growth this year. The customer base has expanded from 70 million–80 million fans when the strategy changed in 2020 to 140 million today; Rubin says the best customers participate across multiple businesses. The ambition is now “one of the most important consumer brands in the world,” serving two billion global sports fans.
- Collectibles shows how Fanatics can expand a category by changing both its products and its partner economics. Rubin puts the business at $5.5 billion this year, versus $500 million in its first year. Long-term guarantees at the 2021 high-water mark, higher royalties, equity and participation in ancillary businesses helped secure rights; he estimates NFL and MLB receipts have each risen from roughly $30 million to $150 million.
- Rubin’s framing of trading cards as “art for sports fans” explains the push into unique objects, achievement and artist collaborations. Debut patches create one-of-one cards tied to an athlete’s first game, while an Ohtani achievement card found in a $1,000 box subsequently sold for $13 million. The business combines product scarcity with broader marketing and athlete participation.
- Sports betting has proved much harder than Rubin expected despite Fanatics’ customer advantage. The company has reached about 10% of the regulated sports market in three years but remains a “distant three.” More than $1 billion of FanCash this year and protection against injury-related losing bets underpin its proposition, while prediction-market competitors inject billions into a finite advertising market.
- Rubin doubts prediction markets will retain their current structure and rejects investing at today’s valuations. He estimates sports represents 80% of their business and sees substantial overlap with regulated betting; state regulation or taxation could change the economics. Fanatics is itself investing hundreds of millions in the category, but his answer on personally backing Kalshi or Polymarket at current prices is “0.0 chance.”
- Protecting partner trust has sometimes required Fanatics to absorb the cost of its mistakes. After Mitchell & Ness deteriorated, Rubin says outside partners received their capital back plus a 20% return; an NFT venture returned more than $100 million after he concluded within roughly three months that it was “at best … a product.” His negotiating philosophy changed from winning the deal to winning the partnership.
- Rubin’s appetite for adversity coexists with a history of severe personal leverage risk. In spring 2009, falling collateral values and tighter lending ratios left him hours from forced sales of his company shares; persistent calls to a hedge-fund manager secured the final repayment money. In March 2011, eBay bought the company for $2.4 billion—his example of why continuing to work a problem matters.
- For Rubin, a “real entrepreneur” remains addicted to the work after financial success. “I’ll stop playing when my heart stops beating,” he says, drawing parallels with elite athletes’ competitiveness. That conviction still needs challenge: despite owning 31% and having supermajority control, he credits a Silver Lake director with stopping an undisclosed bad idea involving “billions.”
1. Relationships earn their value when something breaks
Rubin puts Fanatics at $14 billion in revenue this year, with 22,000 employees and more than 100 locations worldwide. That scale still depends on athletes, leagues and teams choosing to work with it. “When something goes wrong, that’s when relationships get tested”—the reason he treats relationships as part of operating the business rather than a social accessory.
Asked whom he calls for judgment, Rubin names Robert Kraft and his son Jonathan. When an important sports figure maneuvered around an agreement, Rubin wanted an aggressive response. Kraft, whom he describes as 85, reminded him: “You’re in this business forever.” After sleeping on it for a couple of days, Rubin found the issue smaller, handled it rationally and reached a good outcome.
Rubin’s objection to boring billionaire stories is that accumulated wealth alone tells people little; they want the entrepreneurial adventures and “the fuck-ups I’ve made.” That openness also shapes how he seeks help. Calling himself “the least proud person in the world,” he says he readily asks others how they would solve a problem rather than protecting an image of having every answer.
2. A failed ski shop became the entry into closeouts
Rubin started ski-related work at 12, opened a shop in his parents’ basement at 13 and moved into a shopping center at 14. By 16, favorable coverage had encouraged arrogance and spending, including buying half a Porsche with a friend before he could drive. Then it failed to snow: he finished with $200,000 of bills against $80,000 of inventory.
A bankruptcy lawyer helped him recognize the significance of being under 18, and he settled the debts for $35,000. The next opportunity came from another failed store: $200,000 of inventory auctioned for $13,000. He borrowed the purchase money at $1,000 a week in interest, thought that was a good deal, and repaid principal and interest within three weeks.
That transaction introduced him to closeouts. Five years later, at 21, he says the business generated $150 million in annual revenue and that he was making $10 million–$15 million a year. Senra checks whether he was taking that money out; Rubin clarifies that inventory purchases also absorbed it. His conclusion: “Each disaster, if you learn from it, leads to your next success.”
3. A personal margin crisis preceded a $2.4 billion sale
In 2007, Rubin’s personally owned shares in his public company were worth about $250 million. He borrowed against them to fund other investments, an arrangement that had worked since 1999. During the financial crisis, those shares fell 90% to $25 million, while lending advance rates dropped from 40% to 15%. He says his borrowing capacity fell to $4 million from the $50 million he had previously been able to borrow.
Recovering investments from hedge funds and mutual funds reduced the debt to $3 million, but the final amount remained inaccessible. A manager whom Rubin had backed with $5 million repeatedly said he could not return the money. Rubin estimates he called around 100 times before hearing: “Just stop fucking calling me. Take the money back.” He says the repayment arrived hours before the bank would begin selling his shares.
Senra initially describes the subsequent sale as roughly $2 billion; Rubin ultimately specifies March 2011 and $2.4 billion. The buyer, eBay, wanted the company’s e-commerce services for large retailers and brands, which could also bring those businesses into its marketplace. Rubin’s explanation for the changed circumstances is straightforward: the financial crisis had ended, and eBay had a strategic reason to buy.
What surprises Senra is Rubin’s emotional response to the crisis: “It wasn’t scary to me. It was intellectually interesting. It was fun.” Rubin says he kept working rather than becoming frazzled. His qualification matters: continuing to work a problem can “generally” get someone to the right place. His criticism is that many people surrender too quickly.
4. Entrepreneurship means wanting to keep playing
Rubin defines a real entrepreneur as someone born with the inclination, who loves it and cannot stop: “They’re addicted to it.” His counterexample is an unnamed founder who sold for $20 billion, doubled the proceeds through the buyer’s stock and lost interest in building. Rubin respects the financial outcome but questions whether that person remains an entrepreneur. “I’ll stop playing when my heart stops beating.”
Studying athletes has sharpened his distinction between talent and competitive instinct. Tom Brady’s seven Super Bowl wins make sense to Rubin because Brady remains angry about the championships he lost. Rubin sees the same work ethic in Brady’s business activity: “His hustle is infectious.” He argues that exceptional athletes can transfer that combination of effort and competitiveness into their next profession.
Senra supplies Arnold Schwarzenegger’s example: using bodybuilding to reach America, then applying the same principles to acting and business. Rubin focuses on the interpretation of an unhappy background. “Are those excuses or is that motivation?” His entrepreneurial definition is categorical here: obstacles become reasons to persevere, innovate and avoid being run over, rather than reasons to stop.
5. The customer base became the platform strategy
Fanatics Commerce, developed from 2011, is now about a $7 billion business. Rubin describes a combination of design, manufacturing and retail: making licensed products, purchasing from suppliers such as Adidas and New Era, operating league and team websites, owning Lids and running physical venues. Most of the business is direct to consumer, predominantly online; the relationship with fans became the foundation for additional products.
In 2020, Rubin concluded that the most important part of the company was its relationship with 70 million–80 million sports fans. The audience now stands at 140 million, using merchandise, trading cards, marketplaces, live group buying, betting, casino products and Fanatics Fest. “Our best customers are people that do things across multiple different businesses.” The broader opportunity, in his framing, is serving two billion global sports fans digitally.
Rubin expects 40% or more growth this year, “all organic.” Acquisitions have supplied capabilities: PointsBet, bought in 2023 with about 1%–1.5% market share, helped accelerate entry into betting; Fanatics has since reached about 10% of the regulated sports market in three years. Collectibles and prediction markets also involved purchases, but he describes recent M&A as limited rather than the principal growth engine.
Senra compares this with Nikesh Arora’s expansion of Palo Alto Networks through roughly 40 acquisitions, taking its valuation from about $18 billion to $268 billion. Rubin agrees with the underlying multiproduct logic. Fanatics’ leadership studied major technology companies’ first 15 years against their later development and saw substantial growth from additional products. His ambition has expanded beyond becoming the most important company in sports.
6. Betting differentiation must survive difficult market economics
Rubin corrects Senra’s description of Fanatics’ betting proposition as differentiation: the objective is “to be better than the competition.” One mechanism is FanCash earned whether a bet wins or loses, usable across merchandise, additional betting, collectibles and tickets. He expects more than $1 billion distributed this year, with over 90% redeemed within the year. He calls it “the currency of sports.”
The second mechanism addresses bettors’ complaint that an injury caused their loss. Fanatics removes the injured player from affected player props so bets that otherwise would have lost do not lose. Rubin says this has affected tens of millions of bets. He ties the decision to the company’s stated purpose: “relentlessly enhance the fan experience.” A proposed product that cannot do that requires more thought.
Fanatics remains a “distant three,” with Matt King, whom Rubin calls the person who really built FanDuel, running the unit. Rubin describes DraftKings and FanDuel taking their numbers down, investing more, weak growth in existing regulated markets and additional markets failing to regulate. He nevertheless welcomes the competitive problem: “I wanna be at that party. That’s fun.” His leadership theme is equally blunt: “Number two sucks, number one is everything.”
7. Prediction markets carry structural uncertainty despite strong founders
Prediction markets have made betting “much harder than we thought it was gonna be,” Rubin says. Competitors are spending billions in a finite advertising market and pursuing the same customers. He estimates sports accounts for 80% of the prediction-markets business and rejects treating the two categories as fundamentally unrelated: “Let’s not bullshit each other. There’s a lot” of similarity with regulated sports betting.
Rubin thinks the companies have found a way to operate within existing laws, but considers it unlikely that the current market structure will remain in place a couple of years from now. Possible changes include state regulation, state taxation and shifts in political attitudes. Fanatics is investing hundreds of millions in prediction markets while recognizing that uncertainty; participation does not mean underwriting today’s arrangements as permanent.
Senra asks whether Rubin would invest personal money in Kalshi or Polymarket at current valuations. “0.0 chance,” Rubin answers, followed by “Highly short.” He praises both founders as sharp entrepreneurs and strong capital raisers, emphasizing that his valuation view is separate from that admiration. He discloses no actual short position in the conversation.
8. Rights guarantees made a cyclical category investable
The collectibles idea arrived in November 2020; Fanatics launched on January 1, 2022. Rubin saw COVID-driven demand at record levels but little innovation, with expectations of another cyclical decline. His criticism of incumbent incentives centers on Panini, which he says had been for sale for “somewhere between 15 and 30 years straight.” In his telling, pursuing an exit displaced investment in products and marketing.
Fanatics offered rights holders minimum guarantees equal to their high-water-mark revenue, higher royalties, equity in a new company and participation in secondary and ancillary businesses. Agreements could run eight, 10 or 20 years. The duration supported aggressive investment, while the package gave leagues and unions several ways to benefit. Rubin calls it the easiest commercial conversation of his career.
Senra presses on how important the category was to leagues. Rubin says more than 50% of the NFL’s revenue is probably media, and places cards alongside apparel, headwear and video games within consumer products. His NFL and MLB examples each move from roughly $30 million when rights were won in 2021 to roughly $150 million today, both “give or take.”
Fanatics Collect, started three years ago, is expected to handle $6 billion–$7 billion in GMV next year; that is marketplace transaction value, distinct from collectibles revenue. Rubin notes that the company suing Fanatics previously had essentially the same set of rights. He presents the litigation as another fight he enjoys, while maintaining that expanding collectibles benefits rivals as well as Fanatics.
9. Product innovation creates new reasons to collect
The debut patch builds scarcity around a specific event: an athlete wears it in their first game, after which it becomes part of a one-of-one card. Originating in baseball, the concept has spread across the NFL, NBA and global football. Rubin asks listeners to imagine Michael Jordan’s debut patch: “That’s a $50 million card,” adding “maybe more.” That is his hypothetical valuation, not an observed sale.
Achievement creates another collecting occasion beyond rookie status. Rubin describes an Ohtani MVP card incorporating patches from the previous two seasons: a collector found it in a $1,000 box, and it subsequently sold at auction for $13 million. His argument is that the industry had historically underused sporting accomplishment as a source of desirable products.
Marketing and athlete engagement reinforce the products. Rubin cites a statistic that Fanatics and Topps’ trading-card social reach is 100 times its level three years earlier. Brady’s store count has grown from three to 20 in about 18 months. Rubin puts Fanatics’ collectibles revenue at $500 million in its first year and $5.5 billion five years later: “We’re just getting going.”
Asked for the pre-entry industry size, Rubin acknowledges he does not know the exact number: “certainly tens of billions,” then says “it’s probably 5 times” before trailing off. The original ambition was 10X growth; he says it has already grown multiple times. The focus is expanding the industry, rather than directing collectors toward particular cards—a strategy he says also helps Panini, Upper Deck and Pokémon.
10. Entertainment and fine art broaden the collecting proposition
Disney, Marvel and Star Wars are among the fastest-growing properties, “probably even growing faster than sports ’cause it’s a smaller base.” Those relationships were already part of Topps when Fanatics acquired it in 2022. Rubin says collectors commonly cross categories: someone interested in Pokémon may also buy NFL, global football or Disney cards. Very few, in his experience, collect only one thing.
Rubin estimates Pokémon makes more than $5 billion “just from Pokémon,” but explicitly says its exact numbers are unknown. He admires the model’s practical advantages: fictional characters require no autograph negotiations and do not create the same off-field problems as athletes. Senra’s comparison with the art market lands immediately. Rubin’s formulation is “art for sports fans,” extended to entertainment fans as well.
His own view changed sharply. In 2019, buying art for his New York apartment seemed ridiculous; by 2022, he wanted to learn from artists and transfer those lessons into collectibles. Rubin says he owns tens of millions of dollars of George Condo paintings. Condo hand-painted 19 trading cards featuring figures including Brady, LeBron James, Lewis Hamilton and Djokovic. Rubin introduced the collaboration at Fanatics Fest.
The originals will randomly enter packs as one-of-one cards, alongside more widely distributed reproductions and versions signed by artist and athlete. Their eventual secondary prices are left to collectors who keep or resell them. Rubin emphasizes learning from artists’ products and marketing methods, then applying that knowledge to make collectibles more interesting.
11. Winning the partnership includes paying for mistakes and accepting restraint
Rubin says his negotiating objective changed: “I used to always try to win the deal” became wanting “to win the partnership.” Senra connects this to Sam Zell voluntarily paying a lender more to establish a relationship spanning decades. Rubin works with 7,000 athletes on individual contracts and 1,000 sports properties. He wants counterparties to keep returning and “want us to succeed.”
Lids, purchased with Ames Watson, made back 40 times the money in a couple of years, Rubin says. Mitchell & Ness went the other way: hot demand for retired-player jerseys faded, taking the business from substantial profits to substantial losses. Because friends and prominent partners had invested, Fanatics returned their capital plus a 20% return. Rubin calls the acquisition “a really bad deal.”
The NFT reversal was similarly explicit. After raising more than $100 million, Rubin concluded roughly three months later: “This is stupid. This is not a business. At best it’s a product.” Investors received their money back. He treats correcting these decisions as part of preserving a reputation across a long career, including when partners have negotiated better terms than Fanatics.
Silver Lake’s Greg, Rubin’s go-to director, recently challenged a major proposed move. Despite Rubin owning 31% and having supermajority control, the director told him he was making a mistake. Rubin says he was saved from a bad idea involving “billions,” and later called to thank him. He declines further details. His closing explanation is listening: substantial control has not removed the value of someone willing to intervene.
Full transcript
Tell me why you find so many billionaires boring.
When you look at all the people who lead different businesses, they can accumulate huge wealth, but that doesn’t mean they’re interesting. If you go out and talk to a regular person and say, “Hey, here’s some rich guy who made all this money on Wall Street,” that’s not interesting to most people. What people like to hear are entrepreneurial stories. They want to hear not just about all the good stuff, but about the stuff that went wrong.
I’m one of the most self-deprecating people in the world, and people like to hear the stories. They like to hear about the screwups I’ve made, the things that have gone wrong, and the adventures I’ve been through. I think a lot of people are protective of themselves.
1. Being Yourself in Business
I remember doing CNBC four or five years ago, after I’d just been on the weight loss drug. I was the first person to do it. They asked, “Michael, how’d you get so skinny? You must be working out like crazy.” I said, “What do you mean? I took the weight loss shot that everyone’s taken.” They said, “What? No one’s ever admitted that before.”
My PR guy was screaming at me, saying, “You can’t tell people that.” I said, “Of course I can.” And now everyone talks about it. To me, it’s just about being yourself, and a lot of people in business aren’t themselves.
Who are the people you think do a good job of being their authentic selves? What entrepreneurs do you like talking to, or see in the media and think, “That guy knows what he’s doing”?
There could be certain people who aren’t the biggest personalities but are just super interesting. I have so much respect for people like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk, people who’ve built amazing companies that I look up to and think, “I’m inspired by what they’ve done.” I’m always learning from everybody around me. I can take the things people got right, and the things they got wrong, and use all that information to become a better leader.
Say you have a difficult thing happening in your business, like—
That happens weekly.
Oh, okay, so, like—
Probably daily.
Oh, daily. But if you’re thinking, “Shit, I need somebody to organize my thoughts with. I trust their judgment. I think they’re really smart,” who would you call?
It depends what the disaster of the day is. When you run a business like ours—we’re a $14 billion revenue business, one of the fastest-growing consumer brands in the world, I think—and we’re in sports, an area with billions of the most passionate fans in the world, when you get it right, they celebrate you. But if they don’t like something, they bury you. I love that, by the way, because it makes you better. That pressure makes you better.
I go into it expecting that we need to do everything we can to fulfill our brand purpose, which is to relentlessly enhance the fan experience. But shit goes wrong. You have problems daily. Depending on the issue, I ask: is it common sense for us how to solve it, or do we need other people to give us input?
I’m great at asking for input. I’m the least proud person in the world; it’s easy for me to ask somebody for help. If I had a problem, I might immediately bring it up on the podcast and say, “Yo, how would you fix this?” I’m always asking questions.
But is there a specific person you go to? Do you know who Jimmy Iovine is?
Of course.
Yeah, I fucking love Jimmy.
Same.
He was on the show. We’ve become friends. He lives about a mile away from me. I was at his house for lunch a few weeks ago, and he told me that David Geffen gives him the best advice. He said, “I can come to him with what I think is a complicated problem,” and David gives him the shortest path. “This is what he did on the table,” he said, “from here to there.” He thinks there are six things, and David says, “None of that shit matters.”
First, you asked me about interesting entrepreneurs. I think Jimmy’s an interesting entrepreneur.
Yeah.
I remember he told me he’d had a documentary made about him, so I went and watched a few episodes. I thought it was so interesting to see all the things he’s been—
The Defiant Ones. It’s one of my favorite documentaries I’ve ever seen.
Yeah, he—
…ever seen.
And, by the way, I watch very few documentaries, and I really liked it.
Yeah.
I’m still one episode short. I’ve got to finish it.
Yeah.
I think there were four episodes. I got through three and then got distracted with something else.
2. The People He Trusts
To answer your question, if you ask who my go-to person is for talking things through, it’s probably Robert Kraft. Robert and his oldest son, Jonathan, have probably been the 2 people most helpful to me in my career. They’ve really been invested in the growth of everything I’m doing, with no agenda other than to be helpful to me. So if you ask who I’ve asked the most, it’s probably Robert.
I’m not young anymore, but Robert’s 85. He just has more experience. I remember being on a walk with him when somebody did something that completely outraged me.
Can you say what happened? What was the offense?
They made a deal with me and then found a way to be very cute and violate it. It was a very important person in sports. I said to Robert, “I’m really pissed off, and I’m going to be aggressive.”
Robert said, “Michael, take a deep breath. You’re in this business forever. Don’t have a reaction that’s going to create a negative consequence for the long term. Just settle down, sleep on it for a couple days, and then go deal with it.” A couple days later, the issue felt smaller to me. I dealt with it rationally and got to a great place.
There’s a great line in Warren Buffett’s shareholder letters where he says, “You could always tell the guy to go to hell later.” He’s like, “Just sit with it for a few days—
It’s true.
…you’ll calm down, and you’ll be fine.” You said something on another podcast—we were talking earlier, before we started recording—that you don’t really like doing podcasts. You’re the most impatient person in the world. I want to get to your impatience in a minute, because I’m also impatient as hell. But you said something really smart on a podcast that just came to mind.
That won’t happen often.
What?
That I said something really smart.
No. But that’s related to what you just said. You said, “When things are bad, when things are going to shit, relationships are everything.” What did you mean by that?
First of all, relationships are really important in business. I don’t understand how that’s not something so easily understood. By our nature, I try to make Fanatics a very relationship-driven business. Even though we have $14 billion in revenue this year, 22,000 employees, and a global business, with over 100 locations throughout the world where our people work, I recognize we wouldn’t have a business without the tens of thousands of athletes who play on the field, court, ice, and pitch every day. We wouldn’t have a business without the incredible sports properties and teams we work with. We’re humbled by that, so we really want to make sure we have great relationships.
But the reality is, when shit’s going well, those great relationships—of course, everything’s good.
Mm-hmm.
Everything’s going well. When something goes wrong, that’s when relationships get tested. If you have great relationships, as in the example I just gave you, you’ll get back to figuring out how to navigate tough situations if you have the right relationship.
One thing I know in business is that nothing goes straight up. Things go wrong all the time. Anyone who tells you, “Oh, it’s easy, it’s straight up,” that’s like a Disney movie. We’re not here to talk about a Disney movie.
We were talking before we started recording about how, for the last 10 years, I’ve spent my time on my other podcast, Founders, reading hundreds of biographies of history’s greatest entrepreneurs. What’s remarkable to me is how often there was a key relationship in the entrepreneur’s life that was financial, with an investor, a bank, or something like that. The person would find themselves in a shitty spot, temporarily squeezed by a lot of debt, maybe overleveraged, or by a recession or something like that, and the institution would say, “No, cut this guy off,” but the relationship superseded that.
It’s like, “Yo, I’m putting myself on the line.” Phil Knight at Nike has this example. I think Ari Emanuel talked about that in his new book. You see this over and over again. Do you have anything like that?
I mean, here’s the reality. Unfortunately, I’m 54, so I’m not a young buck anymore. Anyone who’s been in business for any period of time has been through many difficult periods. I’ve been through COVID, which was really complicated. I’ve been through the financial crisis of 2008 and ’09, and the internet bubble bursting in 2001.
To me, those difficult times have always been the most interesting times for us to grow through and use to build a better business. I like those times. I’ve seen death in its eyes in business so many times, from the time I almost went bankrupt for the first time at 16 years old.
How do you almost go bankrupt when you’re 16?
Pretty easy answer. You overextend yourself, get arrogant, fuck up, and then it doesn’t snow. I was in the ski business—
It doesn’t snow.
If you’re in the ski business—and I started, I think it’s a pretty well-known story, in the ski business when I was 12 years old. I opened an actual ski shop in my parents’ basement when I was 13. By the time I was 14, I had a ski shop at a shopping center about 10 minutes down the street from my parents’ house. Everything was great at 12, when I had the ski-tuning shop. It was great at 13, 14, and 15.
Then at 16, I thought I was rocking. I believed all these articles and news pieces about this young whiz entrepreneur killing it. I went out and bought half a Porsche with a friend of mine before I was even allowed to drive. I was spending money like I was really successful, except I wasn’t, and it didn’t snow that year.
At the end of the year, I had $200,000 of bills and $80,000 of inventory. I was sitting right in front of bankruptcy and thought I was going bankrupt for the first time. The great thing was, I hired a bankruptcy attorney and ended up realizing you can’t even legally incur debt until you’re 18. I settled my debts for $35,000, then found another store that had gone bankrupt. Their stuff got auctioned off: $200,000 of inventory. I bought it for $13,000.
I went neighbor to neighbor to borrow that money. I found someone to lend it to me for $1,000 a week in interest, which I thought was a great deal for a $13,000 loan. Within three weeks, I was able to pay all the money back, principal and interest, and that got me into the closeout business. Five years later, I was doing $150 million a year as a 21-year-old, making $10 million to $15 million a year. I was the biggest buyer and seller of closeouts.
The reason I tell you this story is that I went from staring death in the eyes, bankrupt, thinking I was a complete failure and giving up on entrepreneurialism, to doing $150 million and making $10 million to $15 million a year as a kid five years later. To me, each disaster, if you learn from it, leads to your next success.
100%. So you’re clipping $10 million to $15 million a year. Are you taking that out as dividends?
We were actually building the business, so I was probably investing back in inventory too—
Okay.
—because I was making real money as a 21-year-old.
Yeah.
And by the way, let’s go back. This is 33 years ago, too.
Yeah, it’s like adding a zero to that.
Add something. A couple times, at least.
You had a couple experiences like this where you were close to losing it. Is this the one where you needed something like $50 million and had to call one of your bankers 50 times? On the 51st time, he finally picks up?
Yeah.
He’s like, “Goddammit, I’ll give you the money.” You were much older then, though. This was during—
That was only—
That was—
—17 years ago.
But this was—
The 2009 financial crisis.
Okay.
We were a public company. The stock I personally owned was worth about $250 million in 2007. I was borrowing money from one of the big banks against that $250 million in stock, and I was investing that money in the market, because that’s kind of how I was living. That worked from 1999 until 2007.
Then, when the financial crisis happened, the stock went down by 90%. My $250 million in stock was now worth $25 million. The advance rates went from 40% to 15%, and I was able to borrow $4 million instead of the $50 million I’d been able to borrow before.
I did a great job getting most of the money back, because all my money was invested in different hedge funds and mutual funds. I got the money back and got down to $3 million, but I couldn’t get another penny out. There was one guy I’d given $5 million to start his hedge fund. I called him—I think 50 times is an understatement. I probably called him 100 times. He kept saying, “I can’t give you the money back.” Finally, he said, “Just stop fucking calling me. Take the money back.”
By the way, I wasn’t days, weeks, or months from being margined out of my company. I was hours away. The crazy thing about it is I loved every bit of the experience. It wasn’t scary to me. It was intellectually interesting. It was fun. I liked the adrenaline of fighting for my life.
Say more about this.
What do you say? If it’s the same shit every day, that’s boring. Business is a roller coaster. Business is an adventure, and if you’re a real entrepreneur, you like that. You thrive on that. Look at the changes that happened in the marketplace two years ago. You could have a red-hot company one day, and three years later that could completely change. I like having to be on top of your game all the time.
This is the same company where you were close to losing it, and then 18 months later you sold it for $2 billion?
$2.5 billion, yeah.
Yeah.
It was—
What was the timeframe there?
In spring 2009, I was going down. I owed $50 million to one of the big banks, which I got down to $3 million personally. I didn’t think I could get the last $3 million paid back, which seems crazy, but I couldn’t get the last $3 million. Again, it was 2009. They were going to start selling the shares to pay off the margin loan, and I got that last $3 million back with hours to spare, not days.
Hours?
Hours. Then, in March 2011, eBay bought the company for $2.4 billion.
How does that happen in such a short amount of time? What did eBay see that was so valuable?
Well, the financial crisis was over.
Yeah.
And eBay really wanted to offer all of the e-commerce services we offered to big retailers and big brands, so they could then get into their marketplace. They had a sound strategy for wanting to do it.
The thing that was interesting for me was seeing some of the darkest days of my business, but I was never frazzled. I was never nervous. I just kept working. To me, if you keep working a problem, you can generally get to the right place. A lot of people give up too easily.
I agree with that. That leads me to the next question. You just mentioned that if you’re a real entrepreneur. How would you describe what you feel is a real entrepreneur? What are the traits, or what comes to mind when you think about a real entrepreneur?
I think being an entrepreneur is something you’re born with. That doesn’t mean it shows all the time, but I think you’re kind of born with it.
I’m going to pause there. On the ride over, what did I say about him? I said, “This dude’s a born entrepreneur.” I used that exact phrase.
The thing is, if you keep it real, I’m like an OG entrepreneur. Now you can look at some 17-year-old kid who’s going to use AI or do something in AI that’s going to reinvent the world in some really interesting way. I was an entrepreneur when the internet didn’t exist when I started. There wasn’t even an internet. Forget about AI. We didn’t have the fucking internet. I was in the real physical world.
When I started as an entrepreneur, if you look back at Michael Rubin in the—can’t believe I’m saying this—mid-’80s, late ’80s, this was such an uncommon story. I always love that. Look, you gravitate to what you’re good at. I sucked at school. I sucked at sports. I loved to work. I’ve always been a workhorse, and I’ve always loved every moment of the action.
Okay, but tell me more about what you see. How would you define a real entrepreneur, if somebody said you have to define one?
I’d say a real entrepreneur, one, they’re born with it. Two, they love it. Three, they can’t stop. They’re addicted to it. I’m thinking of a nameless entrepreneur right now who I have a lot of respect for, but maybe they’re really not an entrepreneur, because they sold the business for $20 billion. They then took stock in the company that bought them, doubled it, and made double their money from that. I mean, the person made tens of billions of dollars, but they’re not an entrepreneur anymore. They don’t care. They’re not—so to me, if it’s in your blood, it’s in your blood. I’m going to do this until the last day I can possibly do it.
Yeah, you’re going to die at the desk.
Yeah. Why not?
Yeah.
It’s fun.
Yeah.
One of the great things about being in business, so different from being an athlete: LeBron James is doing amazing. His birthday’s in December. I think he’s turning 42. He’s eventually going to have to stop playing in the NBA. Tom Brady eventually had to stop playing in the NFL. I’ll stop playing when my heart stops beating.
I love that. You spend a lot of time with these world-class athletes. They’re the best in the world at what they do. They go down in history as such. Do you learn anything from their approach to their craft that you apply to yours?
3. The Killer Instinct
So much. First, I can now tell you—this is interesting, because I didn’t know this 10 years ago—I think when you study an athlete, you can figure out very quickly what they’re going to accomplish. There are so many athletes who are so freaking talented, but they don’t have the killer instinct, and so they’re always going to come up short. There are so many other athletes who are really gifted, maybe not as much as the other person who’s even more gifted, but they’re killers. To me, what I love is studying the people who just always find a way to win.
Everyone knows Brady is a super close friend of mine. Knowing him now as well as I do, it’s so obvious why he won seven Super Bowls. Knowing him the way I know him, he’s still mad he only won seven Super Bowls. We joke about it now: “How’d you lose that one? How’d you lose that?” He’ll tell you the story. He’s angry about whichever one he didn’t win. He’s not happy about it, because he’s that competitive.
For me, I see that same work ethic that made him who he was on the football field in business, and he’s a killer in business because he’s outworking everybody. His hustle is infectious. You see the same thing with Bron. You see the same thing with any incredible athlete who’s got that killer instinct. They’re going to be really successful in what they do after their playing career, because they’re going to take that same attitude and those instincts that made them succeed in sport and put them toward business. I see that translate so well.
Yeah, I think it’s a sign of a lot of practical intelligence to realize that the same principles that let you succeed in one area, if you apply them in another, you’ll probably succeed there, too. There’s this great book written by Arnold Schwarzenegger. It’s called The Education of a Bodybuilder. The first 114 pages essentially serve as an autobiography of the first 30 years of his life. He says, “I grew up in Austria right after we lost World War II. Everybody in my village was a loser. My dad was an alcoholic. Everybody was pessimistic.” He says, “I just needed to get to America. I needed to find a vehicle to get to America. I realized bodybuilding was that vehicle.”
He explains in detail all the crazy approaches he used to get to the top of that profession. Then, at the end of the book, when he’s only 30, he says, “The same principles I used to get to the top of this profession, I’m going to use to go to America, build a business empire, and become the highest-paid actor.” He literally just calls his shot, and then it’s the exact same thing. He just had to apply it and change what he was aiming at.
I never knew any of that story, but here’s what I love about it. So many people would give you the excuse: “His father was an alcoholic, and all these different things went wrong in his life.” The question is, are those excuses or is that motivation? I look at all that as motivation.
Yeah.
A lot of people look at that as excuses. The entrepreneur looks at that as motivation. They don’t give a fuck what’s getting in their way. They’re going to find a way to persevere, find a way to win, find a way to do better, find a way to innovate more, find a way not to be run over.
Yeah. You give me the vibe that you don’t want things to come easy.
It’d be boring.
Right now, what’s occupying most of your mind share in your business?
4. Building a Sports Platform
We have this crazy litigation going on between us and one of our rival competitors. If you look at our business today, we have 3 primary businesses. We have the business we started in, the fan gear business, Fanatics Commerce. We started that in 2011. It’s about a $7 billion business today. We have our betting and gaming business, which is the fastest-growing sportsbook and casino in the country. And then we have our collectibles business.
The betting and gaming business has been much harder than we thought it was going to be because of the advent of prediction markets, which didn’t really exist in any real way even 2 years ago. Now billions of dollars are being spent in a finite advertising market, and that’s made the business far more complicated.
In our collectibles business, we got into a business with so many competitors, but so many of them are so bad and so uninnovative. We got into the business and innovated the product like crazy. We marketed the hobby for the first time. We got athletes who never cared about this hobby before to be so into it, and you see why the collectibles industry is growing so quickly. We reinvented the model. We made it better for everybody involved: the athletes, the hobby shops, the breakers, the collectors, and the sports properties.
There’s a company that used to have really the same set of rights that we have today. They had them before. When they had them, they said they were the global leader in sports entertainment collectibles. Now that we have them, they’ve told us we’re a monopoly, and they’re suing us. The interesting thing is, it’s so intellectually interesting for me. I love the fight.
Out of all your businesses, the collectibles one is the one I understand the least. Why jump into that business? What did you see before you got into it?
What happened was, we built the fan gear business, which we call Fanatics Commerce, from 2011 until 2020.
And this is selling licensed clothing—
Yeah, we’re the designer, developer, manufacturer, and seller of other people’s licensed products. We’re the biggest seller of licensed products in the world, a leading company for many sports properties.
Fanatics.com is where you go. It has really everything that we sell. We sell things from partners like Adidas that we don’t make, or partners like New Era, who are great third-party suppliers to us. We make a lot of what we sell as well, whether it’s the Fanatics Hometown Remix jerseys that we launched last week, or the Nike NFL merchandise, Nike baseball merchandise, or Champion merchandise that we make.
We design, develop, and manufacture many leading products. We also work with so many great brands that we buy from on a wholesale basis and sell at retail. That business is mostly direct to consumer, mostly through the internet. Fanatics is the biggest site, but we also operate the NFL Shop, the NBA Store, MLB Store, NHL Store, and hundreds of college and professional individual team sites. We own Lids, the headwear retailer, and we operate hundreds of venue and college bookstores and venues as well.
If you go to San Francisco, we operate the 49ers venue, the Giants venue, the Golden State Warriors venue, and the Earthquakes venue. We’re a real leader in that business. That’s where we started. Then, in 2020, we realized the most important part of the company wasn’t the commerce business; it was that we had an amazing relationship with, at that point, 70 or 80 million sports fans.
We said, “Well, what else could we do?” We started looking at different categories and entered the betting and gaming business. We’re the fastest-growing sportsbook in the country. We’ve gone from no market share to about 10% of the regulated sports market in the last 3 years.
It’s super competitive, but what we’ve done is make it better for the consumer in everything we do. When we launched that business, we didn’t say, “Hey, how do we just do what FanDuel is doing, or how do we do what DraftKings is doing?” We said, “How do we make it better for the fan?” We launched with 2 big differentiators. The first was that every time you bet with us, win or lose, we’d give you FanCash that you could use to buy merchandise, make more bets, get collectibles, or go to leagues—
It’s like your own currency?
—to buy tickets. It’s like our own currency. It’s the currency of sports.
Okay.
We’re going to give out over a billion dollars of FanCash this year, and more than 90% of it gets redeemed within the year. People love that. If you bet on sports at a regulated sportsbook, you’re leaving money on the table if you don’t use Fanatics, because it’s a better deal: we’re giving out over a billion dollars of FanCash this year.
The second thing is that the number one complaint we heard from bettors was, “Oh, my player got hurt, and I lost the bet because they got hurt.” I thought this player was going to get 50 yards, and they got hurt in the second quarter of the NFL game, or someone gets hurt in a game. So we said, “Look, any time your player gets hurt in a game, we’re going to take them out of the player prop, and bets that would’ve lost now don’t lose.” Tens of millions of bets that would’ve lost now don’t lose. We made it better for the gambler by doing this, and I love that we could do that at Fanatics.
Everything we’re trying to do is figure out how we can relentlessly enhance the fan experience. If we can’t do that, then we’ve got to keep thinking about it. How do we do that?
If I understand this correctly, your idea is like, “Hey, we have 70 to 80 million customers already.”
140 million now.
Oh, but back then—
Yeah.
—we produced this. I think I have an area, one or two ways to differentiate against the existing sports betting, right?
Right.
And I already have—
I’d say better than differentiate. To be better than the competition.
Yeah, that’s right. But one of your massive advantages was the fact that you already had this existing customer base—
For sure.
—that trusted you, had already purchased products from you. So then it’s just extending that relationship and offering them another business line.
Yeah, that’s right.
Okay. These other competitors would obviously have to advertise for a long period of time.
Yeah.
They have to build up their own customers.
Yeah.
But you already had them.
Yeah. Fanatics has really become a digital sports platform. Today, we have 140 million fans who do many different things with Fanatics, whether they buy merchandise, buy trading cards, trade trading cards in a marketplace, go to Fanatics Live and do group buying, bet with us, go to our casino, or go to Fanatics Fest. They do many different things with Fanatics, and our best customers are people who do things across multiple businesses.
Okay, so if you think of Fanatics as a platform, then you’re offering all these other businesses. How many of these businesses are you growing by acquisition? Are you creating these products from scratch yourselves? How do you think about this?
We’re not that acquisitive of a company. This year, we’re going to grow by 40% or more. It’s all organic. Have we bought capabilities to be able to move more quickly? Absolutely. When we got into the collectibles business, we bought a few assets to help us grow more quickly, which we could then materially improve and invest in more aggressively.
In the sportsbook, we bought a small sportsbook called PointsBet in 2023 that had about 1% or 1.5% of the market, just to help us move more quickly. In the last couple of years, though, we’ve bought very few things, and nothing of materiality.
Do you know Nikesh Arora?
I know the name.
Palo Alto Networks. He was at Google for a long time, and you know Masa because you raised money from Masa.
Of course.
Masa recruited him out of Google.
Yeah, yeah, of course I do.
He was like, “Hey, you can be the next CEO because I’m not going to be here forever,” and entrepreneurs never quit. Nikesh was smart. He was like, “I don’t know about this. I’m going to leave Google,” which at the time was the best business in the world. “But if I don’t become the next CEO or you fire me, you’ve got to pay me $250 million.”
Masa said he was going to step down when he was around 60. I think he’s around 59. Nikesh was like, “All right, well, let’s do the transition.” And he’s like, “There isn’t any. I’m not leaving.” So Nikesh leaves SoftBank with $250 million and gets recruited to this essentially single-product company called Palo Alto Networks. I think they have one business. They sell you a firewall. It’s an $18 billion public company. Nikesh takes over, and now it’s worth $268 billion, as of today.
He was just on the show. He said something very similar to what you and I were talking about: “The problem is, I’m knocking on somebody’s door, and I have one product. All the biggest businesses in the world have to sell multiple products to the same customer.” So now he’s done 40 acquisitions. He grew by acquisition, and now he can sell 30 different products to the same customer.
One of the really interesting things for us is that we do a leadership meeting once a year with many of the most important people in our company. This past September, we studied how much a company accomplished in its first 15 years versus today. What you see is that so many of the companies that are really successful today, whether you want to say Apple, Amazon, Google, or Meta, have had so much of their growth come after those first 15 years, and so much has come by adding additional products to the business. So I’d say for us—
That was Nikesh’s point.
Yeah, and he’s 100% right. When we look at Fanatics today, we say a customer can do so many different things with us. That’s certainly a real strategic advantage. When I think about our business opportunity, we used to dream about being the most important company in sports. We have huge respect for that, and our aspirations are much bigger. We want to build one of the most important consumer brands in the world.
The opportunity is massive: to serve the 2 billion global sports fans with many of the things they need digitally. Every time we add a product, it makes our opportunity that much more interesting. A lot of this we can do organically, though. When we got into betting and gaming, we bought PointsBet, which gave us a few capabilities. We got into prediction markets and bought a couple of small pieces. When we got into collectibles, we bought a couple of small pieces. But we’ve very much been an organic grower that sprinkles in M&A to help us get a capability more quickly than we might be able to build it organically.
Yeah. Nikesh was saying, “People come up to me because I bought 40 companies. They ask, ‘What’s your M&A strategy?’” He goes, “I don’t have one. I don’t go out trying to buy companies. I just see where we’re weak in an area and somebody else is better. I want to be number one or two, so then I’ll figure I’ll buy the company and do it that way.”
That was the other theme of our last offsite: number one is everything.
You know, kind of like, number three is irrelevant, number two sucks, number one is everything. For us, I think you need to force yourself to be better, to innovate, to figure out how to be number one. I like the places where we’re a real leader today. There are other places where, like in the betting and gaming business, we’re a distant three today.
I like that challenge: will we get to number one or not? Will we succeed or not? That’s fun to me. People could say, “Oh, my God, look at the betting and gaming business today. It’s an absolute fucking mess. You’ve got DraftKings and FanDuel taking their numbers down, investing more money like crazy. There’s a lack of growth in existing regulated markets, and new markets aren’t regulating. You’ve got the prediction market guys coming in, spending billions of dollars in advertising. Everyone’s fighting for the same customer.” I’m like, “Yeah, I want to be at that party. That’s fun.”
Are FanDuel and DraftKings founder-led?
DraftKings is founder-led, with a really good founder, Jason Robins. FanDuel is not founder-led. The person who really built FanDuel is actually the person who runs our betting and gaming business, Matt King.
Okay, interesting. What do you think of the prediction markets?
I think it’s unlikely that the current construct will be the construct a couple of years from now.
Meaning they found this loophole to—
I like the two entrepreneurs who run Kalshi and Polymarket a lot. They’re very different, but both very sharp. I’ve spent real time with each of them.
It’s been very easy for me to look at markets and make predictions. I feel like we live inside a company, so I can look at something and say, “Man, I know this thing is going the wrong way.” Without calling out people, because I’m friends with a lot of people, I’ve looked at some pretty big companies and thought, “This is a train wreck,” while people were missing it. A couple of years later, the stock is down 75% and still falling. Some things have been obvious to me.
With prediction markets, I think they found a way to work within a set of laws that allows them to do something that, quite frankly, is good for us in the near term. But when someone says, “How much similarity is there between regulated sports betting and prediction markets in sports?”—which is 80% of the prediction markets business—let’s not bullshit each other. There’s a lot, okay?
Do I really sit here today thinking that a couple of years from now, the market construct is likely to be the same? I don’t. You could have state regulation. You could have taxation at the state level. People could just feel different ways. We at Fanatics stay out of politics, but politics change, things change. We know today, while investing hundreds of millions of dollars in prediction markets, that if I had to predict, the market construct won’t be what it is today a few years from now.
Would you put your own personal money into either of those two companies at the valuations they have now?
Zero-point-zero chance.
I thought so.
Highly short. By the way, I like them both. I say this with love to both Shayne and Tariq. They’re both great guys, great entrepreneurs, and great capital raisers. No. Fuck no.
You were explaining to me what I said was the least understandable part of your business, which is the collectibles. I was a kid, I played baseball and basketball, and I collected cards. I never thought to do anything with them. I didn’t even know this thing was still going on. I think I heard you on a podcast where you guys were doing something like $3 billion a year in—
Five and a half this year.
Okay. What the fuck’s going on? Explain this part of your business.
5. Reinventing Collectibles
I think when we got into the collectibles business in 2000, so I—the idea first hit my brain in November 2020, and we launched January 1, 2022—the market had been growing consistently, and then that growth was really exacerbated through COVID. People were inside, looking for things to do, and it was a real COVID beneficiary.
When we came up with the idea, I remember going to the people who ran the sports properties, both the players’ associations and the leagues. I said to them, “Look, trading cards are at an all-time high. They’ve really benefited from COVID, but there’s been so little product innovation.”
Do the leagues make a lot of money from this?
They were making a medium amount of money, not a lot. To put it in perspective, the average league might have been making $20 million or $30 million then, and they could be making—
A year?
A year, from the trading card companies.
Okay.
Or the average union might have been making that. And if you think about FIFA or Disney, which are, like—
When you think about the collectibles market, it’s really a global sports and entertainment collectibles market. Pokémon is the number one trading card company in the world.
How much money do they make?
We don’t know their exact numbers. I’d say they make more than $5 billion just from Pokémon. By the way, they don’t need players to sign autographs. Nobody gets in trouble. It’s very peaceful. All the characters are perfect characters. We look at them with great respect and admiration. Magic: The Gathering, which is owned by Hasbro, is another great business.
For us, when we looked at the business, what we saw was multiple companies that were for sale. The leader at that point, Panini, had been for sale for somewhere between 15 and 30 years straight—literally always for sale.
Are they getting bought and sold over and over?
No.
No one’s buying it.
Never transacted, always for sale. If you’re in that situation, you’re not thinking about how to invest in the product—
Yeah.
—you’re not thinking about how to invest in marketing or how to really build a business. You’re thinking about how to get the check, okay? So time spent on selling was their focus, not time spent on innovating.
And by the way, Topps, the other company, was owned by Michael Eisner, a guy I have huge respect and admiration for. He took it public in a SPAC, and I like Michael Eisner a lot. He—
What? He was taken public in a SPAC?
Yes, he was taken public in a—
Why?
Because he wanted to take it public. Well, look, he’d owned it for a while, and he wanted to take it public. You had two guys in their 70s who owned these companies, and they were more focused on getting cash out of the companies than investing.
We looked at the business in 2021, at the COVID high for the collectibles business. Everyone said this business was going to go backwards, like it had in the past, because it had always been cyclical. We went to the sports properties, the unions, and the leagues, and said, “Look, we’ll guarantee you the high-water mark of the business. We’ll give you a minimum guarantee for what you’re making right now—100% of what you’re making. We’ll give you a higher royalty rate. You’re not making any money from the sales that happen on eBay or Whatnot. We’ll cut you into all of that. We’ll cut you into all these ancillary businesses.”
Oh, so—
And they would never participate in that.
Okay.
And then we said, “On top of it, your product innovation sucks. You don’t actually market this business, and the athletes don’t care about it at all. They kind of get paid to sign autographs.”
For us, the most interesting thing was how fast we innovated the product. I’ll give you a couple of examples. What you’ll know and probably remember about trading cards is that it was always about the rookie. Could you get Jordan’s rookie card? People were always focused on the rookie card.
Our team came up with the idea of developing this debut patch for when a player played their first game. It started in baseball. It’s now in so many sports across the world: baseball, the NFL, the NBA. We just had it in FIFA, the Champions League. You play your first match or game, they put a patch on your jersey. As soon as you finish playing, they take it off the jersey and put it into a one-of-one card. There’s only one in the world.
Yeah.
Could you think about if you had Michael Jordan’s—
Yeah.
Debut patch? There’s one in the world. That’s a $50 million card, okay? Maybe more, by the way. If you had Ohtani’s debut patch, it’d be insane. Tom Brady’s or LeBron James’s debut patch.
So we started creating these patches, and now each year there are thousands of these cards because we’re doing them in so many sports. It’s the number one most desired product.
Everyone wants to get the debut patch because there’s only one in the world. Then the really odd thing was that nobody cared about achievement in trading cards. It didn’t matter if LeBron James had an incredible career or if Tom Brady had an incredible career. People always wanted the rookie cards.
We said, “Well, let’s add achievement to trading cards. Now, when you win MVP, Aaron Judge’s Batman changed to gold color. Then that goes in a one-of-one card. Ohtani had a card we made last year because he was MVP, with patches from each of the past 2 seasons. Someone bought that card in a $1,000 box of cards, and it got auctioned off for $13 million. It got sold for $13 million. That one card.”
So we’re creating these debut patches, making achievement part of trading cards, and then you start marketing. There was no marketing. I just saw a stat that the social media reach of Fanatics and Topps for trading cards is 100 times what it was 3 years ago because people are interested.
Then you look at all the athletes who care so much about this. KAT, I think about KAT spending 5, 10 hours a day collecting cards. He’s so into it. He now owns hobby shops. He—
Wait, who’s KAT?
Karl-Anthony Towns.
Okay.
Basketball player.
Yeah, okay, got it.
You’ve heard of him?
Yeah.
You have?
I only do podcasts. I read books and podcasts.
Only podcasts. That’s it. Okay.
But, yeah.
So there’s this team called the New York Knicks. They won the championship last year.
I am—
This guy, there’s this guy called Karl—
I think I heard about that.
There’s this guy called Karl-Anthony Towns on the team.
Yeah.
And he actually told me that in one of the games he won in the finals, he was so excited to go win an auction on Fanatics Collect that he ran back off the interview to see if he won the auction in the locker room in the middle of the finals. Okay?
So the players are making a lot of money off this now, too.
I think some players are making a lot of money from it, but much more important than that is how much some of the players care about it. Cooper Flagg just opened a store where he’s from in Maine. Lewis Hamilton’s opening his stores in Abu Dhabi, Germany, and England. And Tom Brady has 20 stores now. He had 3 stores a year and a half ago.
So you’ve got the people we look up to, the people who make these cards, now participating and helping drive the industry. I’d say our focus on product innovation, marketing, and having the athletes really engaged in making the product special—like, the athletes didn’t have something to really care about, and now so many athletes want to get their own debut patches. I hear all the time about stories of an athlete who’s like, “I’m getting my debut patch. I want to go chase that card. I’m interested in that card.”
For us, it’s fun that we were $500 million our first year—$5.5 billion 5 years later.
Wait, wait, wait.
We’re just getting going.
Okay, so you mentioned Apple earlier as one of the greatest companies. I’ve read every single biography on Steve Jobs. I’ve done, I think, 39 different episodes on my other podcast about Steve Jobs or people he talked about who influenced his thinking. One of the most remarkable sentences in any book I read about Steve Jobs says that one of his greatest talents was identifying markets full of second-rate talent.
Say it one more time. Identify markets with second-rate talent?
With second-rate talent.
Yeah.
If you look, it’s like he didn’t invent the personal computer. He just—
I might’ve done that in collectibles with third-rate talent.
Okay, well, this is where I’m going. I want to back up and understand: What was the total revenue of the collectible market every year before you got into it? The year before?
I don’t know the exact number. It was certainly tens of billions of dollars, but it’s probably 5 times—I mean—
Okay, so just—
It’s so much bigger. When I got into the business, we said we wanted to grow the business by 10X.
Yeah.
We’ve certainly multiplied it multiple times already. I’d say Fanatics—and we don’t look at how to grow Topps, which we own. We look at how to grow the industry. I’d say the biggest beneficiary of Fanatics is probably a company like Panini, which is currently suing us for having the same set of rights they had. It could be Upper Deck. It could be Pokémon. It could be—
They should be paying me, not suing me.
They should be, okay? Because we’re growing the whole category.
Yeah.
For us, we think it’s our responsibility to grow the category. We don’t tell people what cards to buy. We don’t market cards. We get people excited about the collectibles industry.
Okay, wait. Back up, though. The leagues are making maybe tens of millions from collectibles before you got involved. How much are they making now? Are they making 5X that?
If I think about a specific example, if you talk about the NFL or Major League Baseball—I’m just taking 2 of many examples—they were probably making, the year we won the rights, about $30 million. They’re probably making about $150 million today.
Okay, and how did you win the rights? Because you just—you mentioned earlier, “I’m gonna guarantee you the high-water mark of this industry.” They thought you were crazy for doing this?
In my life, there was never an easier conversation. You go to somebody and say, “Hey, collectibles are at an all-time high in the market. It’s been a category that historically has gone up and down. I’m gonna guarantee you the high-water mark. I’ll give you a long-term commitment of—”
Define long-term.
Some of the deals are 10 years. Some of the deals are 20 years.
Okay.
Some of the deals are 8 years, but I’m gonna give you a long-term commitment that’s gonna allow me to go back and invest aggressively to innovate the entire business.
Yes.
Then I’m gonna give you a higher royalty rate than you’re currently making.
Yeah.
Then I’m gonna set up a new company and give you equity in that new company. So now you’re gonna profit not only from the higher royalty rate and the guaranteed revenue, but I’m gonna give you equity.
And, oh, by the way, you don’t make any money on the secondary business. All the billions of dollars happen at eBay. They make nothing. I’m gonna start a new business that’s gonna be in that marketplace business. Today, we started Fanatics Collect 3 years ago. We’ll do $6 billion to $7 billion in GMV next year. We started 3 years ago.
So we said we’re gonna cut you in on that. One, you’re gonna make money on all these secondary and ancillary businesses you’re not doing today. We’re gonna give you a higher royalty rate. We’re gonna guarantee you the high-water mark. We’re gonna give you equity in this business. And, oh, by the way, we’re gonna innovate the product like crazy. We’re gonna market it like crazy. We’re gonna get the athletes involved.
I remember many of the people in this business saying, “Hey, how long do you wanna go?” I’d say, “I don’t know. You wanna go 10 years, 20 years?” They’re like, “I wanna go as long as you’ll go,” because they looked at this and said this was almost too good for them. They had a category that wasn’t historically a material category. We were coming in and saying we were gonna guarantee and do all these things with our partner, whom they knew so well, because we had such a big business with the sports properties and the unions through Fanatics.
Okay, you just said something interesting. It was historically almost immaterial to them. So educate me about the sports business in general. If I’m a league, is 80%, 90% of the money I’m making from media rights?
Yeah, so I think sports properties globally—I’m including soccer.
You know, as I call it now, football, but it’s soccer to everybody here in America. That’s the biggest sport in the world. College is another massive sport. The NFL is massive. There are so many big sports when you think about it. We’ve used examples like football being the—
Yeah.
—sport I’ve learned the most about in the last couple of years. We have a massive partnership with the Champions League, the Euros, FIFA, and the Premier League, but there are so many other leagues too. LaLiga. Serie A. Each country has its own league. I’d say each sport is different. Some sports have more local revenue; some have more national revenue. The sport with the most national revenue is probably the NFL. More than 50% of its revenue is probably media. Then you have a lot of local revenue because of ticket sales—
Yeah.
—locally, and then sponsorship and—
Consumer products, which is the business that you—
The business we’re in, the industry we’re in, the market we’re in is consumer products, right? That’s what a jersey is, a T-shirt, a trading card, a hat. That’s consumer products.
But you don’t think about collectibles differently from merchandise, like the actual clothing?
The way I think about it is that it’s the consumer products industry.
Okay.
And we think about that industry. Video games are in it as well. You think about the different consumer products. That’s how every sports property organizes its consumer products business. Within that, you have video games, collectibles, apparel, headwear, and hard goods. Some things come and go, too. Digital NFTs came and went pretty quickly.
You went in and out of that business pretty quickly too, right?
I didn’t think I was that fast, but it was pretty fast.
A couple of months?
I got into the business, raised over $100 million from incredible investors, and three months later I was like, “This is stupid. This is not a business. At best, it’s a product, and I’m going to give the money back to investors,” which is what we did. I’m probably the only person to give money back to investors. No one with us lost money. We gave them all their money back.
Okay, so the reason I keep asking how sports leagues make most of their revenue is that I’m still interested in what you saw with collectibles. It’s immaterial to their overall financial picture, and yet this is where the opportunity was. You could take this stagnant market, still doing tens of billions of dollars, with shitty people running it, and say, “I can make this five, 10, 15 times bigger.”
Yes. Check.
Okay.
When we decided to reinvent our business, from starting in the commerce business—what we call fan gear—to becoming a digital sports platform, we had two immediate initiatives: getting into the betting and gaming business, and getting into the collectibles business. We knew betting and gaming was highly competitive, but we had a huge strategic advantage because we had tens of millions of Fanatics customers. Then we asked, “How do we make it better for the bettor or the fan?” By giving fans cash on every bet and by creating fair play.
Yeah.
In the collectibles industry, it’s what you said. We said, “This is a big business that everyone thinks is going to go backwards, but if we get into it, innovate the product, market it, and get the athletes highly engaged, we think it’s a huge opportunity going forward.” We’ve been exactly right. It’s been the same with sports and entertainment. The biggest growth we’re seeing right now is in our entertainment properties: Disney, Marvel, Star Wars. We’re seeing massive growth in those businesses.
Wait, I don’t know about this. What are the entertainment—
Disney trading cards, Marvel trading cards, Star Wars trading cards.
Oh, this has the characteristics of what you were saying with Pokémon, where it’s—
Absolutely.
—like, this guy’s not going to get arrested.
Yeah. Well, we prefer that none of our players get arrested, but that does happen—
But you have—
—shit does happen.
—control over what happens—
Yeah.
—what Mickey Mouse does.
Mickey Mouse is very well-behaved.
Yeah.
I took my kids to Disney this weekend, and Mickey was medium-behaved.
Wait, so how long were you in the sports game before you branched out into entertainment?
We’ve always had a relationship with Disney. We did collaborations between Disney characters and sports properties because it was always a great tie-up, back 10 years ago. When we bought Topps to help accelerate our growth in 2022, they had already worked with Disney, Star Wars, and Marvel, and had been a really important part of the business. You think about Michael Eisner and his great history running Disney. I don’t even know when Disney started working with Topps, but I’m assuming it was one of the things that got Michael Eisner interested, because he ran Disney and then ultimately owned Topps.
Okay. You were saying this part of the collectibles business is the fastest-growing?
Our entertainment properties are some of the fastest-growing, and probably growing even faster than sports because they’re a smaller base. What we see that’s so interesting is someone walks into a Target or Walmart or a CardVault by Tom Brady, and someone’s a Pokémon collector, someone’s an NFL collector, someone’s a global football collector, and someone’s a Disney collector. You see lots of people collecting different things. Very few people collect only one thing. So many people collect across different sports and entertainment properties.
What do you collect?
I’m a real art collector. What’s interesting to me is how I can turn on a dime. When I bought my apartment in New York City in 2019, a good friend of mine said, “Michael, you need great art for these walls.” I said, “Man, I’m not spending any money on art. This is a joke. I don’t get it.”
What year was this?
2019.
Okay.
I was shitting all over art. They said, “No, you’ve got to get art,” and talked me into spending what was a lot of money, but in the grand scheme of things, nothing compared with what I’ve spent on art in the last four years. I bought a bunch of art, which ended up being some of the shittiest art I’ve ever bought. That was what I bought in 2019. When I got into the collectibles business in 2022, I thought, “I want to learn from the artists and bring that into the collectibles business.”
Okay. I could not figure out the collectibles business because I collected cards. I didn’t do anything with them. I’d throw them away. We used to put them in the—
In the spokes. Yeah.
No, in the—
On the wheels.
Yeah.
Yeah.
—and they make that sound on your bicycle and shit when you’re kids. I thought, “Wait, isn’t this just like the art market?” Something you said popped into my mind—
It is.
—like these—
It’s art for sports fans. It’s art for entertainment fans.
Art for sports fans is a great tagline. Think about how big the secondary art market is, the art you have on—
Trillions.
Yes. I’ve done a couple of episodes on Larry Gagosian, and he actually read— I have a funny Larry Gagosian story. His idea was essentially, “I can’t succeed in the primary market, so I’m going to identify where I can succeed.” He made a map of the secondary market and connected buyers to sellers.
Yeah.
He learned some of that from a guy named Joseph Duveen. Joseph Duveen was essentially the art dealer to the robber barons in the late 1800s and early 1900s. He built one of the most valuable businesses in the world with eight to 12 customers. They just happened to be eight to 12 of the richest people in the world, based on a simple insight: Europe has all the art; America has all the money.
I’m gonna take the European art, put it on a boat, bring it to America, and sell it to these robber barons. And he made a crazy amount of money. Half a century later, Gagosian’s reading about Duveen, and he’s like, “I’m gonna figure out a way to build this giant art empire.” And so I’m like, wait, collectibles turned into—
It’s—
Baseball cards turned into—
It’s—
…art for sports fans.
Same. And for me, what was amazing is when the light bulb went off. I’m like, if I get really into art, I can learn so many things from the art industry and then apply those to collectibles. One great example is my favorite living artist, George Condo. That’s his painting right there.
Mm-hmm.
Okay? I probably own tens of millions of dollars of George Condo paintings. George is really culturally relevant. He’s gotta be one of the handful of most successful living artists. One day I said to George, “Hey, do you wanna do a collaboration of really important sports and entertainment figures that you have huge respect for?” He’s like, “Yes.” He actually hand-painted 19 two-and-a-half-by-three-and-a-half trading cards of people like Tom Brady, LeBron James, Lewis Hamilton, and Djokovic. It was amazing for me to see that.
Then we announced this at Fanatics Fest, our sports festival this past summer, and you had Kat and Tom Brady holding these cards up. People were going crazy because we’re now bringing art into collectibles. We’ll have the original cards, one of one, randomly going into packs of cards. But then we’ll also have replicas of those cards that go out in a much wider distribution. George will sign those cards, and the athlete will sign those cards.
Just the idea of taking art and putting it into collectibles—even the way artists market collectibles—there’s so much to learn. Guys like Jonas Wood, who’s actually painted baseball trading cards before and is a really incredible artist, called me to say, “Look, I wanna work together with you.” We’ve already collaborated with my favorite living artist, George Condo, with KAWS, with Mary Kom. We had a conversation with Jonas Wood. I love that. That’s how we learn from people like that. They inspire us, we learn from them, and we use that to make better and more interesting products.
I love the combination of those two ideas. When this artist does these cards, I know you made replicas, but what would the original sell for?
Well, they’re gonna randomly go into packs of cards, because remember, everything in cards is randomized.
Yeah.
So you go get a pack, and you may get—who’s your favorite team? If you had to have a player or a team—
Michael Jordan.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So you wanted to get Michael Jordan. You didn’t know whether Michael Jordan was coming in that pack of cards or not. You don’t know now whether you’re getting a base Ohtani card, or could you get one of these debut patches, and every variation in between. That’s what makes this so exciting.
Okay, so when George Condo is doing this, you’re just putting—
They’re randomly going in packs, and then people who get the better cards, some people keep them, some people put them on eBay, they could put them on Fanatics Collect, and they sell them in the secondary market. And that’s what the leagues and athletes never—and the leagues and the player unions never participated in before. They all participate in the model with us now.
Okay, so Fanatics Collect is the secondary market that they can now participate in?
That’s right.
Okay. When I’m sitting across from an entrepreneur, I’m trying to figure out the archetype, right? I can’t nail your entrepreneurial archetype because I think you’re a combination of several. I think about when you were a kid, you were selling a product, buying it and reselling it door to door, right? There are all these crazy stories I’ve heard about you, where you’re buying all these shoes that they can’t sell, negotiating a crazy price. You say you’ll buy it, you don’t have the money, then you go to the bank and say, “Hey, I’m gonna make a couple hundred grand or a million dollars on this transaction,” then you flip the shoes to TJ Maxx or something before you even take inventory, right?
So you have that natural hustler. If you read these books from the 1800s and 1900s, you’d be called a peddler, which could be a pejorative to a normal person. But an entrepreneur’s like, “Yeah, I fucking—I’m a salesperson. I sell products. This is what we do. It’s not an insult to me.”
Doesn’t bother me in the slightest.
But then you have this deal mind, too. Even the way you structured the deal to get the leagues to agree to do the collectibles with you—that’s a rare combination. Where did you learn about acquiring companies or structuring deals?
I think the school of hard knocks is an incredible school. You just study people around you like crazy. One of the things that’s unique about me is my friend group is probably the most wide-ranging group of people, and I think we all learn from each other. I love that. There’s not a day that goes by that I’m not studying and learning from people around me. I could learn from my four-year-old, who’s talking to me about our Disney products and what she likes and doesn’t like, and whether there’s some new hot thing we need to go get.
By the way, my four- and six-year-olds come and say, “Daddy, why don’t you make cards for this?” I’m hitting people up: “Why aren’t we making cards for this?” And my 20-year-old hates me now that I’m not cool anymore. From the most important people to anybody in the world, I’m always learning from people around me.
But the financial aspect of this—did you learn that from anybody?
I think I learned it from everybody, not anybody. I’m always studying. By the way, I also learned it from screwing things up. I fucked so many things up along the way. I’ve got so many deals wrong. There are so many things you just—
Tell me the worst deal you ever did, or the one that gives you the most pain.
Such a good question. When I started in business, I used to always try to win the deal. As I got older, I didn’t care about winning the deal; I wanted to win the partnership. I’ve become quicker in my negotiating style, and so sometimes you miss things.
I’ll give you an example of two deals we’ve done in the last five or six years. One was Lids, the headwear retailer. Its sales had shrunk, and we bought it with the private equity firm Ames Watson. We put a bunch of our friends in the deal, and it made back 40 times the money in a couple of years. It was a grand slam, like, great. And by the way, the team did a great job. They didn’t fall into it. They earned the success.
Then we bought a company called Mitchell & Ness, which we own today, and we put many of the same friends in it. It had a trend going on in the business similar to what people thought was happening in collectibles, where retired players’ jerseys were really hot. We bought it, and a year later, it just fell out. The business went from making a lot of money to losing a lot of money. We had a bunch of really big-name stars in this deal. I’m like, “We care too much about our partners. Just give everyone a 20% return and give them their money back.” So we just gave them their money back because we wanted to do the right thing by the partners who invested in us and believed in us so much.
It’s not so different from when we fucked up and got into the NFT business. When we bought Mitchell & Ness and it was a really bad deal, we said, “Okay, we’re gonna make it right for people around us, too.” Life is long, and you wanna make sure you have a good reputation. I think always trying to treat people really fairly is very important.
A lot of the sports properties have, in a lot of ways, out-negotiated us in deals, and we’re okay with that because we’re lucky to be in business with them. Even if the NFL does a deal with us and the deal’s too good for them, we’re lucky to be in business with them, and you want the right long-term partnership. These sports properties, man, they are hard. From Disney—I was just talking to a guy who runs consumer products before I walked into this—and we just went through this really long process to do a new partnership with Disney. These things can go on for six months, a year, a year and a half. Both sides are killing each other. But then when you get done, you wanna make sure you got the best out of it, that everyone’s gotten a good position.
I think if you work backward, one of the most important things to understand about you is that I’m going to die on the job. I’m not selling this. I’m doing this forever. What else am I going to do with my life? This is what I want to do.
For sure.
Sam Zell—do you remember that name?
I know who he is.
I got to have lunch with him shortly before he died. How old was he?
How old was he?
He was 82, I think. He had cancer, but I didn’t know at the time. In fact, I was going to have another dinner with him, and then it was canceled the day before because they said he was sick. I thought he had COVID, and he died 3 weeks later. Unfortunately, I didn’t get to see him again. But one thing he told me was, “Hey, I’m going to do deals until I die.” There’s nothing else. This is what I want to do.
One of my closest friends was mentored by Sam for 25 years, and he said Sam was all about relationships. Going back to what you said: “Okay, I’m going to do this till I die.” You said relationships, especially when things are going badly, are everything. Sam would optimize for something other than a transaction, like you just said. Sometimes—
Yeah, but a long-term partnership.
He would raise money deal by deal. Sometimes it was equity, sometimes it was debt. The person he mentored told me this story. He said, “Sam needed $150 million.” I think the industry rate at the time was 7.25%. Sam said, “Great, I’ll take the $250 million at 7.75%.” The banker said, “No, no, I said 7.25%.” Sam said, “I know what you said, but I’m going to pay 7.75%.” When they left the meeting, my friend, who was mentored by him, asked, “Why’d you do that?” Sam said, “On $150 million”—I’m making up the numbers—“it’ll cost me an extra $2 million.”
It’s immaterial, because I’m going to be doing deals with this guy today. This is the first deal we do. I want to do deals with this guy today, a year from now, 10 years from now, 15 years from now. I’m building a relationship with him to show him this isn’t a transaction to me. I want to build a relationship. I don’t want to make just money out here. I want to make money forever, for decades.” You have a lot of that same—
Yeah, he’s right. Look, we work with 7,000 athletes globally today on individual contracts. We work with 1,000 sports properties, and I want to make sure we keep doing more and more with all the athletes and all the sports properties. I want to make sure they feel great. That’s why I said, “Look, things do go wrong, whether we screw things up, something goes wrong in the market, whatever. You want to have a great long-term partnership and people who keep coming back and want to do more with you. I want to make sure people want to do more and want us to succeed. I want people to root for us.”
I know you said you’re learning from every interaction you have, from all the people around you. Is there anybody where you’re like, “Man, I just learned…” Ari Emanuel was just on the show. I just read his book. In the book, he went from agent to dealmaker, and he said the person he learned the most about dealmaking from was Egon Durban from Silver Lake, right?
Yeah. Beast.
Everybody—like my friend Greg Maffei, Michael Dell talks—
He’s a beast.
Everybody was just like—
Three beasts.
Yeah, this is the guy. They actually put me in a group chat with him recently.
He’s our biggest outside investor.
I knew Silver Lake, but I didn’t know if it was—
Yeah.
Okay.
Yeah, Egon is a partner of Greg Maffei, who—
Oh, yeah.
And I love Greg. Greg is kind of my go-to director. I talk to him every week. As a matter of fact, I called Greg this past Sunday night. You’ll love this: it’s not my personality, but I just wanted to say thank you. He said, “What did I do?” I said, “You saved me from something really dumb I was going to do.” I had something I was fixated on doing that was a big deal, and he came to me and said, “This makes no sense. You shouldn’t do this now.” He had a mini intervention with me. He said, “Look, Michael, it’s your company. You own 31% of the company. You have a supermajority. Do whatever the fuck you want, but I think you’re really fucking this up.” He was dead right. I just called him to say I was reflecting on it, and he saved my ass.
That’s incredible.
This is recent, by the way.
Yeah.
Billions.
Billions.
Billions.
Can you say more about this, or no?
No.
Okay, so—
Too easy to figure out.
All right. So Silver Lake is one of your biggest partners. Is there anybody else where you’re just like, “These guys are very sharp”?
Look, I’m lucky. I have a lot of really smart people around me. I’ve got great investors. People talk about having problems with investors, but I’ve never had an issue with an investor in my entire life. I’ve always had great investors in the business. I’m a good listener. I think when you barely make it out of high school, don’t go to college, and have a self-deprecating personality, you develop good listening skills. I’ve got a lot of other things I suck at, but I’m a good listener. That’s really made me appreciate the input I get from people around me, or in this situation, from Greg, when he came to tell me, “Don’t do what you want to do.”
One of my favorite quotes from Michael Jordan, which some people might find surprising given how dominant his personality was, is that successful people listen. Those that don’t listen don’t last long.
I think that’s 100% right.
Michael, this was awesome. Thanks for welcoming me to your house and doing this.
Absolutely.
Appreciate it, man. That was awesome.