After The Builders: On Musk and Thiel
Oz WoloshynMangesh HattikudurMax ChafkinFaiz Siddiqui
- The Roadster demonstration sells Musk’s spectacle before it establishes a deliverable product. Chafkin calls it “a pitch for the stock,” with customers unable to buy the car and production promised for 2028. Siddiqui’s sharper product question: does combining a supercar with rockets create the equivalent of an amphibious vehicle—“not a great car, not a great boat”?
- Musk’s AI safety argument combines truth-seeking with a belief that curiosity will favor humanity’s survival. A curious AI, he argues, should find a prosperous, multiplanetary civilization more interesting than human extinction. Siddiqui thinks the discussion drifts away from proving safety; Chafkin sees “don’t be boring” as a revealing account of Musk’s marketing power.
- Musk admits getting carried away in government while continuing to finance Republican politics. His regret centers on visibility, presidential pageantry and time diverted from AI, even as he defends electing Trump to steer policy toward a freer market and less bureaucracy. Chafkin expects him to become a major J.D. Vance backer if Vance wins the Republican nomination in 2028, which Chafkin considers the most likely outcome.
- A central tension in the panel is whether Musk’s politics damaged Tesla or improved its competitive position. Siddiqui emphasizes an eroding customer base; Chafkin argues subsidy removal pushed competing automakers outside China away from EVs while Tesla repositioned around AI. Against political contributions he puts at “probably almost $700 million,” Chafkin describes a large increase in Musk’s wealth, while admitting he has not recently checked the math.
- Thiel’s investment filter prioritizes a purpose beyond making money, without clearly equating ambition with moral goodness. He ranks a moral compass highly but describes Mars primarily as “transcendent,” remaining uncertain where it belongs on a good-versus-evil scale. Chafkin’s reading: Thiel has a moral framework, but its definitions differ substantially from conventional ones.
- Competition with China reinforces Thiel’s commitment to AI acceleration even when emerging capabilities look dangerous. “We need to hit the accelerator as hard as possible,” he says, arguing that controlling AI requires developing AI. Siddiqui hears “nuclear arms race rhetoric” and wants to know whether any red line would change that position.
- Thiel fears catastrophe narratives could empower global political control, but allows that some forms of global authority could be good. He cites existing nuclear arrangements as “definitely more good than bad.” Chafkin closes with the competing political principle: “there is no guarantee that we live inside of the brains of these people”—democratic societies retain a choice.
1. Musk’s spectacle turns technical ambition into market attention
- Woloshyn opens with the contradiction connecting Musk and Thiel: extraordinary success has preserved their underdog identities. Siddiqui asks what Musk still wants after accumulating businesses across cars, space, social media and AI. Chafkin asks the equivalent of Thiel, whose bets on Palantir, SpaceX and Facebook helped turn an outsider into someone with enormous power.
- For Chafkin, the Roadster demonstration revealed no new technology and promoted a car customers cannot buy. Even under Musk’s stated 2028 production timeline, he says customers would not be able to drive it. His interpretation: “it’s a pitch for the stock,” making “Elon Musk, the technologist” increasingly difficult to distinguish from “Elon Musk, the meme.”
- Siddiqui acknowledges the spectacle works initially: “It’s a flying car.” Examining the footage leaves him unsure what the underside contains or how the demonstration relates to a customer’s eventual purchase. His product objection is the amphibious-car problem: “not a great car, not a great boat.” Does the combination satisfy either supercar buyers or people seeking flight?
- The excitement also appeared short-lived to Siddiqui. During Tesla’s hour-long earnings call, the Roadster largely served as a backdrop photograph; analysts were not clamoring for details, though Tesla was touting record reservations. He was surprised by “how quickly that excitement faded.”
2. Musk’s AI safety argument becomes a story about himself
- Asked why truth-seeking and curiosity make AI safer, Musk argues that forcing AI to believe two mutually consistent things could make it “insane.” Curiosity supplies a separate mechanism: an AI should want to see humanity prosper and become multiplanetary, because “a future where there are humans on multiple planets is more interesting” than one without people.
- Musk then makes the conditional simulation argument: if simulation theory is correct, boring simulations would be terminated, so continued existence suggests an interesting one. “The most important thing is just don’t be boring.” Siddiqui hears coherent free association that leaves Isaacson’s safety question unresolved. Chafkin agrees, while seeing Musk’s willingness to be weird as central to his appeal, marketing ability and power.
- Siddiqui’s reporting supplies a more personal explanation for the urgency. When someone asked why Mars had to happen now, given that humanity could advance over centuries or millennia, Musk’s reported answer was: “I want to be the one to do it.” Hattikudur connects that insistence to Musk’s self-image as an underdog and warrior responsible for moving civilization forward.
3. Political regret coexists with a contested financial payoff
- In Isaacson’s clip, Musk still defends electing Trump for freer markets and less bureaucracy, but admits getting “carried away” by presidential pageantry. He says he should have stayed in the background and returned to AI sooner. His substantive justification for leaving: there was “no way we were going to solve the deficit from within the government”; Woloshyn says Musk blamed Trump’s desire to be liked.
- Siddiqui calls the departure account “retconning”: Musk’s work was becoming unpopular, his relationship with Trump was fraying, and Tesla’s customer base was eroding. Musk ultimately accused Trump of being in the Epstein files, Siddiqui says. He also says pressure from climate advocates and people sympathetic to the climate movement in California was driving Musk away from government and undercutting Tesla’s business. Trump’s display of a red Tesla on the White House lawn illustrates the business pressure. The surprising admission, for Siddiqui, is that someone already so wealthy could still find proximity to the president intoxicating. Chafkin questions whether Isaacson is pushing Musk toward regret.
- Chafkin counters that “it worked,” at least “for now”: subsidy removal hurt Tesla’s margins but, he argues, caused “every other automaker” outside China to abandon EVs, while policy enabled an AI rebranding. He estimates contributions rose from $300 million to “probably almost $700 million,” calls Musk a trillionaire and describes wealth up “threefold or something like that,” adding, “I haven’t done the math recently.”
- Siddiqui adds an indirect benefit: Tesla’s latest slight demand bump, he says, reflects high oil prices following a war started by Trump. Meanwhile, continued Republican donations complicate talk of withdrawal. Chafkin expects major Musk backing if J.D. Vance becomes the 2028 Republican nominee, which he considers most likely. He says that if Ken Paxton wins the Texas seat and Republicans hold off Democrats, Musk will deserve credit; if Democrats do well, he expects them to rake Musk over the coals for two years, perhaps longer depending on 2028.
4. Thiel cultivates opposition and defines purpose on his own terms
- Hattikudur recalls Musk estimating that 75% of America likes him based on his Twitter comments. Chafkin contrasts that appetite for approval with Thiel’s willingness to have enemies: “being a supervillain is his brand.” He thinks Thiel cultivates both admiration and fear, because being perceived as evil can also communicate capability.
- Chafkin nevertheless preserves a distinction from his own reporting. Thiel declined an on-record interview for his critical biography but did not subject him to meaningful intimidation: “He basically allowed me to do my job.” Chafkin still argues that the Gawker case chilled journalism and expanded wealthy people’s perceived options for intimidating reporters; his personal experience does not erase that wider effect.
- Thiel’s stagnation critique also looks weaker to Chafkin when examined through privilege. Complaints about the absence of faster planes make sense from a private-jet cabin, he argues, while ordinary passengers have experienced substantial improvements in air travel. The criticism is that a rich person’s frustrations can be mistaken for a comprehensive assessment of technological progress.
- Asked where a builder’s moral compass ranks, Thiel answers highly, then pivots toward “some transcendent purpose.” Mars qualifies because it exceeds a “short-term coin operated business,” although he does not know exactly where it belongs morally. Chafkin hears a contrarian struggling to give an unconventional answer to an obvious question: Thiel believes in good and evil, but defines moral superiority differently from most people.
5. China makes AI danger an argument for faster development
- Thiel “broadly” agrees with Trump and David Sacks that competition with China argues against an AI pause. He acknowledges discomfort when major AI companies themselves recommend slowing down, but explicitly rejects changing camps: “We need to hit the accelerator as hard as possible.” The discomfort affects how readily he makes the argument publicly, rather than his stated position.
- The causal chain is defensive: “you have to develop the AI technology to control the AI technology.” If China develops threatening capabilities, maintaining the lead becomes more imperative. Recent alarming developments can therefore strengthen his acceleration case. Asked whether removing China would make a pause more attractive, Thiel replies, “apart from that, how was the play, Mrs. Lincoln?”
- Chafkin sees ideology and portfolio interests fitting together: acceleration benefits Thiel’s investments, though companies warning about AI may also benefit financially from those warnings. Siddiqui’s objection is the escalating logic itself—“nuclear arms race rhetoric.” He wants to hear whether any red line could produce support for a pause; if none exists, he considers that revealing.
6. The Antichrist argument turns AI governance into a struggle over authority
- Isaacson frames Thiel’s warning as a political mechanism: an aspiring world ruler could gain power by persuading everyone that catastrophe is coming. In that account, “The Antichrist wouldn’t seize power by creating an AI apocalypse, but by convincing everyone that the apocalypse was coming.” Thiel says he is tempted to take a victory lap.
- Thiel contrasts early modern fears of a technological conqueror with his account of present politics. Rather than a weapons builder imposing control, fear of science and technology could mobilize support for powerful global institutions. Climate change becomes his example of a problem that appears to require global regulatory authority.
- The qualifications matter: “I don’t think Greta is the Antichrist,” Thiel says, and “there are real fears.” He also allows that versions of global authority “could be good.” Existing nuclear arrangements, he says, were “definitely more good than bad.”
- Chafkin interprets the broader worldview as privileging rule by Thiel, Musk and similar technologists, with technological imperatives taking precedence over democracy. His closing challenge returns to the show’s question about whose imagination society inhabits: “there is no guarantee that we live inside of the brains of these people.” Members of democratic societies, he argues, still get to decide.
Full transcript
Welcome to Tech Stuff. I’m Oz Woloshyn, and we’ve got a special episode today. Kaleidoscope, the podcast network I co-founded, has a new podcast out this week called The Builders with Walter Isaacson. I wanted to bring on my co-founder, Mangesh Hattikudur, to talk about what motivated the project and share some clips from the first 2 episodes: interviews with Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, 2 figures we talk about fairly frequently on the podcast and who don’t do sit-down interviews all that often.
Joining us to break the interviews down are 2 of the foremost journalists and chroniclers of Musk and Thiel: Max Chafkin, a Bloomberg Businessweek columnist and author of The Contrarian: Peter Thiel and the Rise of the Silicon Valley Oligarchs; and Faiz Siddiqui, a technology reporter for The Washington Post and author of Hubris Maximus: The Shattering of Elon Musk. Welcome, both.
Hey, thanks for having me.
Hey.
Thank you for joining us. Before we get into it, I’d love to hear a little bit from both of you about your reporting on these 2 figures. Max, maybe let’s start with you. Having written the book on Thiel, what’s your biggest open question about him?
I think the big open question on Thiel is that he’s been around the world of tech since before I became a tech journalist, around 2005 or 2006. But for most of my career, Thiel was making all these long-shot bets to create this way-out-there view of the world, on a political dimension as well as a technology dimension.
After many of these out-there projects have really paid off, Palantir being probably the most notable one, I think the big open question is what he wants now. Thiel also had a hand in SpaceX, some of Elon Musk’s companies, as well as Facebook. These are now some of the biggest and most powerful companies in the world. Thiel was also notable as an early supporter of Donald Trump and a pioneer of the effort to bring Silicon Valley closer to the American right wing. All that has happened. So part of the big question I have is: What does he want now? And where is he, given that he’s gone from being an outsider to being in a position of incredible power?
Very interesting question. And Faiz, what about you? You wrote the book on Elon. What’s your biggest open question about him?
What does he ultimately want out of this? He’s the world’s richest person. He controls the world’s most valuable automaker, a company at the forefront of space exploration, and the dominant social media platform for political discourse. He’s also controlling one aspect of that firm that’s heavily focused on artificial intelligence bets.
And yet he’s so full of grievance. He still seems angry, still has that sort of underdog mentality, and feels like it’s him versus the world. What does he want? The book seeks to explore that question and also examines the forces that allowed him to accumulate so much power.
I think that’s something that shines through in both of them. These are 2 people who basically achieved almost everything they set out to achieve, beyond their wildest dreams, and yet still find a way to be motivated by the sense of being an underdog, which is kind of extraordinary.
1. Why The Builders Exists
Just to give a little more context on The Builders, I started my career as a producer for Charlie Rose and grew up with the idea that interviews with historical figures in real time could become interesting documentary evidence, both for the moment and for the future. So we approached Walter and said, “You have this extraordinary ability to drive FOMO among the people in the world who can have everything else. But sitting with you and being part of the Walter Isaacson, Da Vinci, Einstein, Musk, Jobs legacy is incredibly compelling. We think we have a real chance of getting all these people to sit down with you, and perhaps doing it in a way and tone in which you don’t often hear them speaking.”
Mangesh, tell us a bit more about the inside baseball and what it was like to actually book these guys. What was it like to get Elon to do this?
We really wanted to figure out whose imagination we’re going to be living in and collect these thoughts from the biggest tech geniuses, leaders, and influencers of our time. We thought, since Walter had written the Elon book, that it would be an easy ask and probably an easy get from the start. But we got a lot of no’s from him. We had approached him first. Walter approached him, and it had been the better part of a year. He’d said no, so we were moving along with the other interviews. I really didn’t think it was going to happen.
The timing is so strange. My cousin told me, “Let’s go to a World Cup game.” He had an extra ticket, so I went to this France-Sweden game. You know those moments in sports when something extraordinary is happening, when you feel like you’re watching a no-hitter or someone has a hot hand? Mbappé gets the ball, and he’s cutting through 4 people. Walter Isaacson calls me. Walter doesn’t call me; he normally texts. I put it on silent immediately because I’m watching this moment, and I think, “Oh, wait, maybe it’s something important.” Right as Mbappé cuts through all these people and shoots on goal, I look at my phone, and it says—
“Elon is in.”
So we got Musk to say yes. We’d set up the cameras, and Walter was twiddling his thumbs. The interview’s supposed to start, and Musk isn’t getting on. He isn’t getting on. David, one of our colleagues, looks and realizes Musk’s just been tweeting. And that’s what gets him away. But then they get on Riverside, and they’re so comfortable with one another that the intimacy was really interesting to see. The way he opened up about Trump, getting carried away, and things like that wasn’t what I expected him to say.
We’re going to go to some clips from the interview shortly. But first, Max and Faiz, what’s the context we need to know here? It’s obviously been a huge week for Elon. Faiz, you’re on deadline for good reason, no doubt, but can you give us the breakdown between the Gibney documentary, Starlink, and the midterms? What’s the moment in Musk land?
It’s one of those moments when things are quiet in Musk world—or, as I’ve described it, really disquieting—and then the complete opposite happens, where everything seems to be happening all at once. You mentioned the 4-hour documentary that dropped, examining Elon Musk. There was also a great Wall Street Journal scoop on Elon Musk seemingly unilaterally slowing down Starlink, according to the Journal, in response to what he saw as Ukrainian offensive use of this technology, which is intended for defensive use, if I’m reading between the lines correctly on Elon.
He argues that there’s a system called Starshield for those sorts of military purposes that’s in the control of the U.S. government. In any case, the Journal reports that Musk has slowed down Starlink use on the Ukrainian front. There were also SpaceX earnings and Tesla earnings, 2 major milestones. For SpaceX, it turns its first-ever profit, at least since going public. Meanwhile, Musk is tweeting up a storm about the midterms and the potential for him to be investigated after the midterms. There’s just a lot going on in his world.
That last point, I think, is very important. The idea that Musk left politics is funny. A year ago, or whatever it was, a little over a year ago, Musk gave up his position in the White House and left in a blaze of glory—I don’t know if it was glory, maybe infamy—hurling insults. There were mutual recriminations. Within a couple of months, they were right back together. And they’re back together now.
Musk is less central. You don’t see the kind of PDA-level affection that maybe we saw during the 2024 campaign. But Musk is donating record-breaking sums to the Republicans right now. If somehow Ken Paxton manages to win the seat in Texas and Republicans hold off the Democrats, it will be thanks to Elon Musk, I think. Conversely, if Democrats do well, we’re going to spend 2 years watching them basically rake him over the coals, and potentially longer, depending on what happens in 2028. He has made himself a central figure in Republican politics for a very long time.
All of what you say is true. It’s somewhat surprising that Elon said in the interview on The Builders that he actually regretted some of his involvement in politics. We’re going to get to that in a second. But first, I have to ask you both about the Roadster. Underwhelmed?
I’m sorry.
But I think it’s—my understanding is that we didn’t really see any new technology here. What we saw was an awesome, Evel Knievel-style pitch, but it’s weirdly a pitch for a car that does not exist, in the sense that you can’t buy it. And even if you follow the Elon Musk timeline, which is, “Oh, we’re going to start producing it in 2028,” you’re not going to be able to drive it.
So what I think it’s actually a pitch for—and this gets to a lot of what is happening and what has been happening with Elon Musk in recent years—is the stock.
It’s like a memification of this guy. At a certain point, there’s Elon Musk the technologist, and there’s Elon Musk the meme. It’s become harder and harder to distinguish those 2 things.
I think that was well said. It was pretty clear to me what was going to happen when we saw this demo. Reporters are naturally skeptical, and they know a dog-and-pony show when they see one. But I see this thing and I’m like, “Oh, okay, this is going to be a thing. People are going to notice this. It’s a flying car.” Then, as you go frame by frame, it sort of becomes clear that you’re thinking, “What am I looking at?” When I really inspect the underside of this thing, what is in there? And how does it correlate to what a customer might receive a year or 2 from now?
Second, I made this point on a different podcast. It’s this question of: Okay, it’s a supercar, and maybe it flies. It has rockets. Call it a gimmick, whatever it is. Aren’t you kind of building the equivalent of an amphibious car, where it’s not a great car and not a great boat? Is this really what people who want a supercar want, or what people who want a flying car want?
Lastly, I’ll note that it didn’t really register in Tesla’s earnings. There was an hour-long earnings call, and there was very little. The only way it registered was as the backdrop—the photo they showed for the call. It’s not like investors and analysts were clamoring for details on this. Tesla was touting record reservations.
It wasn’t.
I was just shocked at how quickly that excitement faded.
I think Elon recently said, “A friend of mine, Peter Thiel, once said, ‘The future promised us flying cars, but instead we’ve got 140 characters.’” Well, not anymore.
That is what he said. I hate to be the person to pour cold water on it, but it didn’t definitively answer that question. It didn’t put that question to rest.
Yeah, well, you can have more than 140 characters, though. Elon Musk has, in—
Taking over Twitter, he has changed that. So credit where due.
Well, it’s an amazingly self-referential post from the owner of X. But let’s play the first clip about Elon’s mantra, which comes back to this overarching question: Whose imagination do you want to live in? Here is Walter asking Elon what type of AI he thinks humanity should be building.
And if you make it maximally truth-seeking and curious, like you say, I don’t quite get it. Why does that make it safer?
Well, if you’re forcing AI to believe 2 mutually consistent things, you can make it go insane. An insane AI, I think, is not a safe one. Then, curiosity is important because a curious AI is going to want to foster humanity, to see how we turn out. What happens to a humanity that prospers and becomes multiplanetary? I think a curious AI will want to foster humanity, because a future where there are humans on multiple planets is more interesting than one where there aren’t any humans on the planets.
So the most interesting outcome is the most likely? Yes.
Well, generally, I think that’s true for a different reason, which is that if simulation theory is correct, then any simulations that are boring will be truncated. Therefore, the fact that we exist means that we’re an interesting simulation. Really, the most important thing is just don’t be boring.
This explains you a bit. You’re on a crusade against being boring.
I don’t know. There are odd things that happen in this simulation, especially if you’re me. Think about it. If you’re me, you’re like, “Should all these things really be happening? Should I really be making spaceships to go to the moon and Mars? What the—” That doesn’t seem real.
Faiz, I’m curious. What do you make of this?
It was a classic Elon—what should we call that? A train of thought. It felt like he was answering a question that Isaacson didn’t really ask. He was just free-associating there at the end. But they are coherent thoughts, unrelated to the question, which is: How does this make us safer?
Isaacson is channeling Elon. He definitely knows the answer to the question he’s asking, like, “So the most interesting outcome is the most likely?” That’s just a classic Elon perspective. But it doesn’t really—I don’t know—it felt like a tangent or free association in the end.
Max?
Yeah, I agree with everything Faiz just said. But, leaving aside the philosophical stuff—his interest in simulation theory, which comes up all the time—I do think his idea of not being boring, which he didn’t quite articulate but almost did, is central to his rise and to one of the ways he’s made himself an appealing figure in people’s lives. It’s a big source of his power. People talk about Elon Musk the technologist, but he’s an amazing marketer. And that idea of being unafraid—
To be weird or—
Self-referential, or to go on a slightly bong-hit-style free association, like, “What if it’s all—what if this is all a dream and somebody else…” That’s interesting.
And it makes him different.
And some of that difference is what has allowed him to get this massive following of people who basically hang on his every word.
I definitely don’t count myself among that number, but I have to say, when he asked that rhetorical question—“Should all this stuff really be happening? Should one person be able to do all this?”—it made me think a little bit of the title of your book, Faiz: Hubris Maximus. It is weird. We live in weird times, and I think Elon is very symbolic of that.
Yeah, I think he has created an environment where he’s uniquely equipped to pursue all of these bets at once. There’s an anecdote in the book where someone pulls him aside and asks, “Humanity is almost certainly going to progress beyond where we are now in hundreds or even thousands of years. Why go to Mars now? We don’t necessarily need to do it right now if we understand that humanity will progress.” According to my reporting, Elon’s reaction is, “Yes, but I want to be the one to do it.”
He’s sort of created this problem for himself that he’s obviously very incredulous about. He’s like, “How did this end up being the case? How did I end up here?” It reminds me of his reaction to becoming the world’s richest person, which was incredulity. But, okay, back to work.
And it goes back to the points I think both of you are making: He really sees himself as this underdog-warrior, right? He has to be the person who’s moving things forward, making these dreams possible. That plays into so much of his ethos.
It’s funny. We put the episode up on YouTube, and the most-liked comment was somebody noticing that he’s playing an RPG in the background. So there’s that.
Do we know what he’s playing?
Mangesh, should you figure it out?
We did, but I’ve forgotten it now.
Let’s turn to politics. I thought the most self-reflective moment was actually about his involvement in politics. Let’s play the tape.
You just said something interesting about your year away from xAI and everything else in government and politics. Do you feel that that was too much of a distraction? In retrospect, was it misbegotten?
I think I had it going for too long. A lot of people will disagree with me about this, but I think it was important to elect President Trump to steer things more in the direction of a free-market economy, with less bureaucracy, ideally. It was interesting to go around with President Trump on Marine One and Air Force One and all that sort of stuff. But what I should have done, I think, was be more in the background.
But was that too seductive, in a way?
It was a little bit.
Yeah, you seemed to get a bit too intoxicated by it, in a way, with the chainsaws and all that.
Yeah, I think that’s true. I got carried away, basically. I ended up leaving sometime in May.
That was a weird weekend.
Yeah, it was.
Tell me about it.
No, no, I can’t. Let’s not take up the—let sleeping dogs lie, or whatever. Let’s not put a spade down in the backyard, type of thing. You never know what you’re going to find. But anyway, the point is, I should have gone back and focused on AI a little sooner than I did.
And when he gives you a golden key, did you kind of feel relieved? Like, “Actually, this has been intoxicating, but I can do more if I go back to my businesses”? What did you feel when you said, “Oh, man, I’m exiting”? Maybe that’s not the worst thing.
Well, actually, the thing is, I came to the conclusion that there was no way we were going to solve the deficit from within the government.
Impossible.
And he goes on to say the reason it’s impossible is because President Trump wants to be liked too much to make the hard decisions.
How do you understand this sense of regret about his involvement with DOGE, but also the enormous binge of check-writing in the last couple of weeks?
It feels like a bit of retconning. He wasn’t just organically retconning; he didn’t make a decision to leave in a vacuum. His work was becoming increasingly untenable and unpopular. His relationship with the president was fraying. He ultimately accuses the president of being in the Epstein files, and everything goes down in flames.
I think the most revelatory part, though—and I’m shocked that he admitted it—was his intoxication with the pageantry of it all, like being on Marine One. It’s wild to me that someone so rich and powerful can still feel something unfulfilled, some fantasy or whatever, by being next to the president on a helicopter. That was revelatory to me. But as for his view on why or how he left, I think that answer would have been more interesting a year earlier.
I—
He didn’t want to put that spade down into the backyard, sadly. I would have wanted to know what he had in mind.
I agree.
In those questions, I almost felt Walter pushing Elon toward regret. Does Elon really regret it? I can’t quite tell from what he’s saying. I think it’s because there’s a disconnect between where Elon Musk is politically and where a lot of his following is. His following sees him as a very effective technologist, not as the primary financier of the far right around the world, or as somebody who was ruthlessly laying off government workers, including parts of the government responsible for saving millions of lives in Africa.
It was an incredible and disorienting moment in which Elon Musk’s brand as a green technologist and a very effective technologist kind of fell apart. He was ineffective, as Faiz is saying, and he was pushing policies that vast parts of his fan base profoundly disagree with. It’s very hard to hold those 2 things in your head, and it’s not clear to me that Elon himself quite knows how to square that circle. He keeps talking about stepping away from politics and then keeps writing these massive checks.
And I fully expect that if J.D. Vance is the Republican nominee in 2028—which I think is the most likely scenario—Elon Musk will be a major backer of J.D.
Backer of J.D.
Vance. He’s going to be back on Marine One, possibly, assuming he can’t contain himself.
Let’s not forget, Tesla was in hell. They had people throwing—I don’t know, Molotov cocktails, whatever was happening at the Tesla showrooms—and the stock was a bloodbath. Trump had to essentially attempt to prop the company up or whatever.
By bringing the red Tesla onto the White House lawn.
You may read that more generously as doing a favor for a friend, as inappropriate as that would be given their positions. But there was a lot of external pressure driving Elon away from government. It wasn’t just a matter of, “I was too enamored by this and maybe stayed too long.” It was, “No, you’ve now undercut your business.” As Max points out, that was driven largely by climate advocates, or at least people sympathetic to the climate movement in California. There was a base for this business that was clearly eroding because of his decisions.
I feel compelled to point out, though, that it worked. As much as I think there are ways in which, if Tesla were to collapse in a few years, we’d look back on the dalliance with Trump as the beginning of that, it’s been really good for Tesla and for Elon Musk. His net worth has gone way up.
It’s true that Donald Trump got rid of the subsidies that were a big part of Tesla’s profit margins and, as Trump likes to say, got rid of the electric mandate. But that’s kind of worked for Tesla because it’s caused every other automaker outside of China to give up on EVs. In a way, it’s cleared out a bunch of companies that were starting to present a real threat, while creating policies that have allowed Elon Musk to reshape the company as an AI play and put the car business aside.
You look back on this and ask, “What did he get for his $300 million, now probably almost $700 million, in political contributions?” His net worth has gone up threefold or something like that. I haven’t done the math recently, but he’s a trillionaire. It’s worked incredibly well, at least for now.
Look at the weird dynamics with Tesla itself. Yesterday, in its earnings report, it reported a slight demand bump. Why is that happening? Because oil prices are super high because Trump started a war. There are roundabout ways, even if there are also direct ways, in which decisions were made that were going to benefit Tesla. Elon can look back at this and say, “I’ve done the right thing,” despite the cost to everything and everyone around him.
Mangesh?
I was going to say that the intoxication of the chainsaw stuff and all that was surprising. Also surprising to me was that he says, “I think 75% of America likes me,” because he’s looking at Twitter and sees in his comments that that’s what people think. I do think there’s a way in which that moment was such a valley compared with the SpaceX IPO being such a peak. There is some regret because he was perceived publicly in a bad light during that moment, but obviously it’s a net win for him.
From Elon Musk to Peter Thiel. I want to play some clips from that interview. But before we do that, Mangesh, what were some of your favorite behind-the-scenes moments from this one?
In the way that I was a little too optimistic that we’d get Musk, I was completely pessimistic that we’d get Thiel. He’d done that Douthat interview, and that pause had gone viral.
The pause about whether humanity should—
Should continue to exist. People were commenting, “Is this like a computer glitching?”
Right.
One thing we discovered was that Thiel actually has multiple copies of Walter’s books.
I did hear that. I did hear that.
And so we thought, “Oh—”
There’s a sliver of a chance. We were talking to people on every continent, trying to figure out how to coordinate them. So many of these interviews just fall apart the day of. All these people talk about how much they love canceling interviews. You talk to eight handlers. You have security sweeps of the studios, and eight bodyguards traveling with various people. Then they decide they just want to go out for coffee with Walter instead of doing an interview. That wasn’t the case in this one, but it was the case in some of the others.
I was kind of stunned that we got Thiel on tape. Both of you, Max and Faiz, know this world better, but I was stunned by the particular type of charisma Thiel had in person. The pauses do exist on tape, but they don’t exist in person in the same way. You think about the Gawker lawsuit, the Antichrist, and the shadowy work he does behind campaigns. It’s interesting to see that charisma in person, and to see why Zero to One is such an important book to Silicon Valley.
Max, did you get any legal threats for your book?
No, nothing of significance. I always feel compelled to say that the book I published is fair, but critical. It’s not the Thiel fanboy perspective, although that perspective is certainly included in the book. I approached Thiel and attempted to secure his participation. Through the process, he kept me at arm’s length.
I met with him. There was some back and forth, and I met with him off the record in a meeting that I describe in the book, although I didn’t quote from it. Sometimes people won’t speak to you but seem interested in seeing the book published. Toward the end of the process, that wasn’t the vibe I had.
I have to say that I wasn’t subjected to intimidation. He basically allowed me to do my job, allowed the book to exist, and allowed critical journalism about him to exist. That’s very obviously different from the Gawker situation. I feel compelled to say that because what he did to Gawker—you can debate the ethics of it—had a real chilling effect on journalism and the profession of journalism.
And it changed how many, many wealthy people relate to the media. It kind of opened it, moved the Overton window on what is permissible in terms of what you can do to intimidate a journalist. At the time, Thiel said, “No, no, no, that is not my goal.” He’s always said he didn’t want to do that.
It was a specific instance.
Do you believe that?
Well, I don’t know if I believe it, but I do have to say I feel like it’s an important fact that, in this one case, he didn’t, you know what I mean?
Like, he lived his values, if those are in fact his values.
Max, I’m not really a Premier League guy, but I think the Overton window is closed and has been closed.
Well, it’s better than a Manchester United window, that’s for damn sure.
But, Max, you did meet him. Were you surprised that he looked you in the eye? Having met some of these other founders and stuff, and seeing the way they have difficulty communicating, I was kind of surprised by that.
I found Thiel to be a very interesting subject and endlessly fascinating because he’s a guy with all these contradictions. He’s also somebody who is not as afraid. Like Elon Musk—the point you made about 75% of America liking Elon Musk—he wants to be loved. He’s got this feeling that I think many people who perform on stage have: he gets a real charge from the crowd, and he reads his mentions. If somebody somewhere says something negative about Elon Musk, there’s a very good chance that Elon Musk will see it and remember.
And Thiel, it’s not like he isn’t aware of his critics. He’s hyper-aware of his critics, but—
He’s also somebody who is not afraid to have critics and, throughout his career, has, I think, almost valued it. He has this superhero persona with his fans and a supervillain persona with the people who do not like him, who see him as this kind of inventor of shadowy technologies that do surveillance and shadowy right-wing stuff. I would argue that he has cultivated both of those brands. Being a supervillain is his brand. He kind of likes it, I think, and I’m not sure if he would ever admit that.
But he has talked about it at times. I think even recently, in a public interview somewhere—I can’t remember—he talked about how being seen as evil is not necessarily the worst thing in the world, because it’s being seen as capable.
That’s organic transmission of content to the world that we love.
I have to say, I saw that clip and I was like, wow, he’s saying this thing that, in my book, if you go and look, is attributed to somebody—a friend, I forget—but it’s not an on-the-record assessment. Seeing him come out and say it was staggering, but I definitely think it’s true. He understands the power of being reviled or being feared. That’s a compliment in a way.
But also, everything’s chess to him, right? It feels like everything’s just thinking steps ahead, which he even says is why he goes silent, right? He’s trying to think about what the response is and how he responds to that response.
Right.
It is an interesting perspective versus the sort of racing to have a certain feeling of joy or elation or whatever.
You say in the interview that the DMV is bad and evil is better than bad. In the moment, I was like, well, that’s kind of compelling and quite funny and interesting. But then I thought afterwards, I’m not sure if you can really say that evil is better than bad. I kind of get what he’s driving at, but also, that’s a little spooky.
One of the feelings I’ve had in consuming every piece of Thiel writing and content is that his critique of government has always felt a little bit thin to me. Is this a guy who spent a lot of time at the DMV?
I’m not totally sure.
He’ll often say things about the post office. He’ll make comments about how terrible the experience is at the post office or the DMV. A lot of his critique of dysfunction is more just some inconvenient parts about being a rich guy, and is actually a lot thinner than many of his fans think.
He’s constantly complaining about air travel, and how a key part of the stagnation thesis for Peter Thiel is that we haven’t gotten faster planes. That’s an observation that makes sense if your main experience of air travel is the cabin of your own private jet. Whereas, if you’re a regular person, air travel has gotten so much better in that period. It’s a perspective informed by a lot of privilege, in a way that I think actually makes the critique less strong than it could be.
This is how you get USB ports in the seats before you get a transit line to another neighborhood, right? What do people who are just seeking these sorts of luxuries want out of the experience, versus what is actually going to improve the experience for everyone? I don’t know, it’s just such a great point that you just made, Max. Why do we take this seriously, other than the fact that Thiel holds a tremendous amount of power? It’s not necessarily a serious critique, especially if you’re bringing up the DMV as somebody who has not spent a significant amount of time at the DMV recently.
I think it’s a good moment to go to our first clip. Walter has this framing of Peter as somebody who invested in Elon and financed Vance, and basically, as the kind of meta-concept of the series, The Builders, that Thiel is someone who’s kind of like a builder of builders. So let’s roll that clip.
If you were to back a builder, though, where would you rank having a moral compass?
I rank that highly. I would say, I don’t like investing in companies where it’s simply a business. There’s some transcendent purpose. There’s something very important that you’re doing. Elon going to Mars is—I don’t know exactly where I would rank that on a moral good-versus-evil dimension—but it is transcendent. It’s somehow not just a business. We’re not just a stock brokerage where we’re making a few dollars every time people buy and sell stocks. It’s not just the sort of short-term, coin-operated business. It has this transcendent sense of purpose. That’s what I like.
First of all, Thiel’s talked about this, but he has this problem. The title of my book is The Contrarian. He’s a contrarian. This is one of the problems if you’re a contrarian: there are certain things where it’s hard to be contrarian about a question like, “Should you have a moral compass?” You could almost hear him trying to think about how he can give an interesting answer to the question, because he doesn’t want to just say yes. But he did say yes, in a way, right? He gave his own definition of what he would see as morality and purpose in a company.
I do think he very much has that sense of a worldview that includes things like good and evil and so on. It’s just a very different definition of what moral superiority would be to most people.
2. The AI Antichrist Debate
I think, for a final clip, the politics and geopolitics of both of these figures, and China, are a really important and fascinating thread. Walter was asking Peter what he thought about this in the context of whether or not there should be a pause on AI development.
Your old friend David Sacks and, of course, President Trump are now saying, because of the competition with China, stop talking about pausing AI, even if you think it could be an existential threat. Do you agree with that?
Yes, I broadly agree with that. The challenge is that I’ve been friends with David Sacks for many decades. The thing that makes me less comfortable making those kinds of arguments publicly is that, on some level, it’s hard when the big companies themselves are telling you to stop and to slow down.
So that’s caused you to have some pause, because you were not in the pause-button camp.
Well, I’m still not in the pause-button camp. I’m saying this on your show: I’m not in the pause-button camp. We need to hit the accelerator as hard as possible.
Well, wait a minute. Let me stop there. Why haven’t the past few weeks caused you to be more amenable to a pause button? It’s pretty scary, that hugging phase.
I think, in some ways, you have to develop the AI technology to control the AI technology. If you assume China will develop things like that, it’s more imperative than ever that we stay ahead of them. So, if you look at it geopolitically, maybe you can even interpret something like the hugging phase thing as, it’s so imperative that we not lose the lead and that we get cyberattacked to death.
Walter went on to ask him, “Well, if there was no China, would you be more amenable to a pause button?” To which Thiel replied, “Apart from that, how was the play, Mrs. Lincoln?”
Lincoln? Which gave us a chuckle in the control room. But what I mean is, how do you interpret this mix?
So his comment about accelerationism—we should hit the accelerator. Let’s make the AI better. That’s very much in line with his overall worldview, which I alluded to earlier: tech is not doing as much as it could. A lot of technologists share that perspective. Even a lot of people in AI share it: they’re not as worried about what this technology could do as what it can’t do.
I will say that Thiel is a guy who talks his book and who has often melded his ideology with his business portfolio in a seamless and very interesting way. Saying that being pro-acceleration in AI is definitely good for business and good for his financial portfolio makes sense. I also think it’s worth applying the same filter to some of the people who are calling for a pause. Some of these AI companies also stand to benefit financially from some of the warnings they are issuing. So I think it’s a somewhat calculated comment.
Just as a casual observer, it feels like nuclear arms race rhetoric. It’s just like, “Oh, yeah, they’re building something really powerful. We have to build something equally powerful.” Where does it stop? Is there anything—I guess I would have liked to hear whether there was any red line, anything that would get him to maybe endorse the idea of a pause. If there isn’t, I think that’s quite revelatory.
Thiel’s been going around the world, essentially saying that anyone who wants to rein in the technology industry is a candidate for the Antichrist—that this is such a dangerous ideology that you should think about it in those terms. Look, he’s a provocateur, somebody who likes, as I said, to say controversial things and watch people react.
I also think he correctly senses that this is a reaction to a very, very powerful and nascent political movement that is skeptical of tech and technology. Thiel is picking up on something significant in the culture and in our world. You can disagree with his reaction to it: “Push that aside. We need to stamp it dead.” Whereas I think it’s very reasonable to ask, as Faiz is saying, “Where’s the line?” There’s probably a line somewhere, and it’s pretty weird not to say there is one. But again, I think he’s reacting to something significant. Thiel is very good at picking up these trends early, and I think that’s what we’re watching right now.
We’re going to roll a clip of Peter Thiel talking about the Antichrist.
Let me read you something you once said, because I’m wrestling—and I mean this genuinely—with the whole Antichrist thing and what you mean by that. It ties into this new AI moment we’re in. You said, “The way the Antichrist would take over the world is you talk about Armageddon nonstop. You talk about existential risk nonstop. The Antichrist wouldn’t seize power by creating an AI apocalypse, but by convincing everyone that the apocalypse was coming.” Is that what’s happening now?
Well, since I said that about a year and a half ago, I’m tempted to take a victory lap of sorts. You have to at least ask certain questions, and that’s what I would want people to do.
But explain to me, though, what you mean by the Antichrist.
It’s a medieval biblical concept of a tyrant who will somehow rule the entire world at the end of history. If you think of it in a literary or creative way, you can ask, “How would the Antichrist come to power in different times and different places?” In early modernity, in the 17th and 18th centuries, perhaps the Antichrist would use science and technology to build weapons and take over the world.
In my telling, in late modernity, we still think of the Antichrist in 17th-century categories. We still think it’s a Dr. Strangelove, Edward Teller-type person who builds nuclear bombs to conquer the world. But if you think of it as a political dimension, the way I think the politics work in our society is that the fear of science and technology is far more powerful, and that’s the kind of thing that would really crystallize things. I don’t think Greta is the Antichrist, but I think environmentalism—there are real fears.
People pushing back on progress is what you’re saying.
Pushing back on progress, but then also pushing for these very, very powerful global political structures. Something like climate change sounds like the sort of thing where you need a global regulatory authority.
So your big fear is some global regulatory authority?
Yeah. And again, there are probably versions of that that could be good. The nuclear ones we ended up with were definitely more good than bad.
Max, last word to you.
Yeah, I mean, I think Thiel’s worldview is—we opened the show talking about living in these guys’ heads—I mean, Thiel’s worldview is that he, him, himself, and people like him, including Elon Musk, should run the world, and that technology should be the imperative through which we structure our society at the expense of democracy. I think that is interesting and worth discussing, especially in societies where we’ve decided democracy is a good thing.
But I always feel compelled to point out that there is no guarantee that we live inside the brains of these people. That is what they very much want. We members of a democratic society get to decide. The fact that that is so terrifying to them is interesting and worth exploring, especially in the context of a democratic society with an election coming and so on.
And that indeed was the mission of this show, The Builders: to reveal these people in their own words. You can listen to it wherever you get your podcasts, and find it on YouTube. Fez and Max, this was a fascinating and very revealing conversation and analysis. Thank you both so much.
For joining us. Thank you so much. Thank you.
For Tech Stuff, I’m Oz Woloshyn. This episode was produced by Eliza Dennis and Mangesh Hattikudur. It was executive produced by me and Julian Nutter for Kaleidoscope and Katrine Norvell for iHeart Podcasts. Jack Inslee mixed this episode. Kyle Murdoch wrote our theme song. And please check out The Builders wherever you get your podcasts.