Y Combinator · · 2 min
Paul Graham: When should you launch your startup?
TL;DR
- Paul Graham argues that launching late is riskier than launching early. Waiting carries its own downside: "There's a risk of launching late too."
- Launch when one person gains a capability they previously lacked. Graham calls this "a quantum of utility": someone is glad the product exists because it lets them do something new.
- If launching would make nobody happy, the product is not ready. Graham's minimum requires an identifiable benefit: "here's this thing I can use."
- [Speaker?] questions whether one happy user is enough when 100 are really unhappy. The objection is tentative: "maybe it's not ready."
- Graham endorses launching with 10 enthusiastic users while everyone else is indifferent. Responding to a benchmark attributed to Paul Buchheit, his instruction is "totally launch."
Digest · the substance, structured for research
1. Delaying launch carries the greater risk
- Graham's starting point is categorical: "the risk of launching early is not as great as the risk of launching late."
- Both choices carry risk, so founders need a rule of thumb for deciding when to launch.
2. One newly enabled user meets the minimum
- Graham describes what a "minimum viable product" must contain as "a quantum of utility."
- His concrete test is one person saying, "I can do X, and before that I couldn't do it."
- The boundary works both ways: if launching means "no one would be happy," Graham says the product is not ready.
3. User dissatisfaction complicates the threshold
- [Speaker?]'s pushback introduces a hypothetical: one happy person alongside "100 really unhappy" people means "maybe it's not ready."
- The same speaker cites Paul Buchheit's benchmark: "10 people who really love your product" is "a good place to be."
4. Concentrated enthusiasm is enough when others are indifferent
- Graham agrees that 10 people who are "super excited" justify launching: "totally launch."
- His endorsed scenario pairs that enthusiasm with "nobody else cares." He calls that outcome "perfectly fine" and "great."